Chapter 4

The phone call cut off abruptly.

Probably no signal out on the Caribbean, or maybe Nathan had finally hit a dead zone.

The morning disruption left me wide awake.

I felt a scorching gaze on me.

I shifted, the heat rising to my cheeks as I remembered the raw, electric intimacy of the previous night.

Caleb broke the silence, his voice low and steady.

"Rosie, you knew it was me from the very start, didn't you?"

I nodded.

"I've known you two since we were kids. Even with the identical faces, I’ve never once mixed you up."

Caleb’s eyes searched mine, flickering with a hidden, fragile hope.

"Then why choose me yesterday?"

"Because," I said, meeting his gaze squarely, "you are the one I chose to be my groom."

Caleb let out a short, incredulous laugh. "So Nathan thought he was playing you, thinking he’d successfully swapped places for his little escape. He has no idea he’s the one being played."

But by noon, the "perfect" plan hit a wall.

Nathan, who was supposed to be halfway to the Caribbean with Sadie, burst into our master bedroom.

He grabbed Caleb by the shoulders and shoved him toward the master bathroom.

"Caleb, switch suits with me. Now! I need my identity back."

Before Caleb could respond, Sadie trailed right behind him, ignoring the security detail at our door.

She didn’t even glance at me. She marched straight to the bathroom door, her voice trembling with manufactured fragility.

"It’s my birthday, Nathan. Just come out and spend it with me, please?" A sob hitched in her throat.

"We promised. You said last year you’d make it up to me. Just this once."

I felt a cold sting in my chest.

Last year, on my birthday, I’d been in the hospital after a car accident. Nathan had told me he was stuck on a business trip in London. Turns out, he was busy playing hero for Sadie.

The bathroom door swung open.

Nathan stepped out. Seeing Sadie’s tears, his face softened into that mask of patronizing comfort. He pulled her into his arms.

"Don't cry," he murmured. "I’m here. I’m not going anywhere."

Sadie clung to him, her shoulders shaking. "I knew you wouldn't leave me."

Caleb just gave them a look of cold indifference and stepped toward me. "Rosie."

Nathan finally noticed I’d been sitting on the sofa, watching the whole pathetic scene.

He hesitated for a second, then forced a smile.

"Hey, since it’s Sadie’s birthday, why don’t the four of us go out and celebrate? Brother, she’s your old friend from the same college. You don’t mind, do you?"

His tone was sharp, a veiled threat directed at his brother.

Caleb didn't even acknowledge him. He looked down at me, his eyes softening instantly.

"What do you think, Rosie?"

I stood up and looped my arm through Caleb’s, my posture firm.

"No thanks. We have an appointment at the City Clerk’s office this afternoon to officially file our marriage paperwork."

Nathan’s eyes widened. "You’re what? You're filing for a marriage license?"

His composure cracked, his face twisting into a mask of ugly shock before he smoothed it over with a strained, plastic smile.

"Right. Well, we wouldn't want to hold you up then."

Before he walked out, he shoved his state ID into Caleb’s jacket pocket, leaning in to whisper.

"I know you’re trying to defend Rosie. You faked that whole thing on the phone this morning just to piss me off. But you have to know I’m not betraying her."

"I’m just helping Sadie fulfill her dream of traveling the world. I promise, after today, we switch back. I’ll make it up to Rosie."

He tapped the pocket where he’d just dropped the ID. "Take my ID. Go to the City Clerk's office and pretend to be me to file that marriage paperwork with her."

He straightened up, his eyes locking onto Caleb’s. "You handle the paperwork for me, and I’ll overlook this little mutiny."

The door clicked shut behind them.

Caleb reached into his pocket, pulled out Nathan’s ID, and tossed it into the trash bin without a second thought.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter