Chapter 5
Seeing this, everything clicked in my mind.
Nathan still thought Caleb was just playing a part for him.
How arrogant.
He had no idea that his former fiancée and Haverford Holdings were about to slip right through his fingers.
Inside the City Clerk’s office, filing our paperwork was a breeze.
Thanks to my family lawyer stepping in right before the wedding, Caleb and I had already quietly voided Nathan's original marriage license and secured a new one.
Now, we just had to hand over the documents signed at our ceremony.
The clerk reviewed the signatures, stamped the official seal, and handed us our finalized Marriage Certificate.
The names printed on the crisp, legally binding document were crystal clear: Rosie Stirling and Caleb Haverford.
Right on cue, a text from Nathan popped up on Caleb's phone.
"Did you get the marriage license with Rosie yet?"
"Send me a picture right now."
"You're doing me a huge favor, man. Once I take over Haverford Holdings, I'll split my shares with you."
Caleb casually snapped the photo of the legal documents and hit send.
Miles away at the marina, Nathan stared at his phone in frustration.
Caleb had sent a photo, but out here by the docks, the cell reception was terrible. The image was nothing but a blurry thumbnail with a spinning loading circle.
"Damn it, load," he muttered. Losing his patience, he hit the call button to ring Caleb, wanting to confirm that the filing was done.
Before the call could even connect, Sadie’s delicate hand covered his screen, canceling it.
"Today is my birthday. It's the last day you're spending with me," she pouted, her eyes glistening with unshed tears.
"I don't want to hear about paperwork or another woman right now."
She leaned against his chest, her voice softening. "You gave Caleb all your signed documents, didn't you? He's your identical twin. He walked into that office looking exactly like you and filed your paperwork. What could possibly go wrong?"
"Come on, the yacht is waiting." With a swift, practiced motion, Sadie swiped left and deleted the loading message from Caleb entirely.
"Eyes only on me today, remember?"
Hearing Sadie's soft words, Nathan’s brief anxiety melted away.
She's right, he thought.
Caleb had his documents. The marriage was legally his.
He reached out, intertwined his fingers with Sadie's, and shoved his phone deep into his pocket.
Because of that, Nathan never saw the photo finally load in the background.
The photo that clearly displayed the groom's name: Caleb Haverford.
Sadie grabbed his hand. "Nathan, the yacht is here! Come here!"
He looked over at her.
Sadie jogged up the ramp onto the luxurious Caribbean private yacht, spreading her arms toward the ocean breeze.
She suddenly turned back and flashed him a radiant smile.
"Nathan, thank you for spending my birthday with me."
Nathan didn’t reply. He just stared at her, lost in a daze.
His mind drifted back to the first time they met.
He was representing Haverford Holdings at a major alumni donation gala at their Ivy League alma mater. Sadie was one of the scholarship recipients.
While all the other students tried to suck up to him, calling him "Mr. Haverford," Sadie just looked him in the eye and called him "Nathan."
She had walked with him around the campus quad and bought him a cheap slice of pizza from the student cafeteria. She laughed and scolded him for being a picky eater.
"Don't tell me the big, bad CEO is scared of a few veggies?"
Looking at her playful, mischievous smile, it was the first time he felt like simple food wasn't so bad after all.
He found out she was a junior in his old major.
They exchanged numbers, but Sadie never once texted to bother him after that day.
That was, until two months later. She suddenly called him late at night, sobbing.
When he rushed over to her tiny apartment in a panic, he found her standing there, holding a cheap grocery store cupcake with a single lit candle.
"Nathan, I'm so sorry. I didn't mean to bother you," she choked out, her eyes red and puffy. "Today is my birthday. I just... I didn't want to be alone. It's too lonely."
Her voice cracked. "I scrolled through all my contacts, and you were the only one I felt safe calling. Could you just... stay with me for a bit?"
His heart had melted instantly. Right then and there, he promised he would spend every birthday with her from then on.
Back then, she had smiled at him with tears in her eyes and said the exact same thing:
"Nathan, thank you for spending my birthday with me."
The face from his memory perfectly overlapped with the woman standing on the yacht now.
Nathan stopped hesitating.
He locked his phone, shoved it into his pocket, and strode onto the deck.
Whatever. Today was the last birthday he would ever spend with Sadie.
Once today was over, he would immediately swap identities back with Caleb.
Everything would go back to normal.
And Rosie would never find out the truth.
