Chapter 2

Why can't you be more like her?

Sooner or later, everyone Audrey won over asked me that.

At nine, I'd fallen down the back steps of the orphanage and broken my leg.

Ms. Bennett had stood above me as I lay on the concrete, pale and hurting.

She'd spoken without a trace of concern.

“I pay a little attention to Audrey, and you go and injure yourself deliberately.”

“Who taught you to manipulate people like this? Why can't you be more like Audrey?”

Ethan had done it, too.

Once he knew Audrey, he'd begun looking at me as if choosing me had been an unfortunate purchase.

“You were raised in the same orphanage,” he'd say with a sigh. “Why aren't you even half as clever as she is?”

In that parking lot, I watched my family drive away with Audrey in the back seat. I might as well have been nine again, lying on those steps.

All the warmth I'd allowed myself that evening was gone.

Three days later, they offered an apology gift.

An exhibition of my paintings.

Mom took both my hands. She looked at me so tenderly.

“Your childhood was so hard, and you kept painting through all of it. That's an extraordinary thing, Nora.”

“Now people are finally going to know who you are.”

“Nothing is more precious to us than you and your art.”

“That's why we're calling the exhibition PRECIOUS.”

My eyes burned. It took so little to make them do that.

I began to hope again.

These people were my family. We shared the same blood.

Perhaps that really could make a difference.

Then I looked around and found Audrey beside Logan, their shoulders almost touching.

Just like that, I stopped hoping.

Logan cleared his throat.

“Audrey helped us organize everything. We owe her for that.”

My stomach sank.

I hurried through the gallery entrance.

And came to a halt.

Mom followed me in and drew a sharp breath.

The labels beneath the paintings all bore one name.

It wasn't mine.

Audrey Blake.

Red flashed in Dad's eyes.

“What the hell happened here?”

A gallery employee rushed up before Audrey could say anything.

“I'm so sorry. Ms. Blake is well known in art circles. We assumed it was her exhibition when we received the booking.”

“To be honest, no one knows who Nora Whitmore is.”

I felt the humiliation of it.

Audrey moved in front of me, tears already running down her cheeks. There was amusement in her eyes.

“Nora, I'm so sorry.”

“I grew up without parents. I've never had any money or an exhibition of my own. I couldn't have known they'd do this.”

I trembled so badly that my teeth ached.

I wanted to shout the truth to the entire gallery.

It was a lie.

She'd arranged this.

She'd done the same thing all my life. Whenever something mattered to me, Audrey made sure it became hers.

I turned to my family. All three looked angry.

I only wanted one of them to tell her it wasn't fair.

Instead, Logan smiled gently at Audrey.

“Hey, there's no need to feel bad. If anything, your name will help Nora out.”

I gave up waiting for someone to defend me.

“I painted these,” I said, my voice breaking. “This exhibition is mine. Why is her name on it?”

Dad directed his anger at me.

“Audrey's a far better painter than you. Now you want the labels changed and the whole family embarrassed?”

Mom tried to calm things down.

She did it from her place in front of Audrey.

“Audrey has no one, Nora. No parents to love her as we love you. Can't you spare a thought for that?”

“It's a single exhibition. Stop being selfish.”

She then instructed the staff to replace my paintings with Audrey's.

My work wasn't polished enough, she explained. It might damage Audrey's reputation.

The reporters turned up exactly when they were expected.

With great reluctance, my family put Audrey in the gown they'd chosen for me.

She posed between my parents and smiled for the photographers, occupying my place.

Above them, enormous silver letters still spelled out PRECIOUS.

Below that sign, my paintings had been crammed into a trash can.

For a long time, I couldn't move.

Then I pulled out my phone.

I bought a one-way plane ticket for the following morning.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter