Chapter 2

I stepped out of the walk-in closet, looked around the empty living room, and lost myself in thought.

The apartment was more than two thousand square feet. Nathan had called it a gift to me, a thank-you for standing by him when he had nothing.

I'd believed him. But he never brought up adding my name to the deed, not once in all those years.

I should have understood what that meant. I'd mistaken a place in his life for a life of my own.

My phone vibrated. Nathan had texted.

“Made it to the hotel, Claire. No need to worry.”

Usually, I'd call right away. Was he tired? Had he eaten? What did he have planned?

This time, I didn't want to ask any of it.

After staring at the message for a while, I wrote, “Okay.”

“You're not yourself today,” he replied. “Tell me if something's bothering you. You don't have to deal with it alone.”

Then another message: “Don't forget to eat dinner.”

He sounded considerate. There was nothing in those words I could argue with.

“Fine,” I sent back.

That ended the conversation.

I supposed Sophie was keeping him busy.

The thought sent me rushing to the bathroom. I stayed there for a long time, dry-heaving.

Sophie's secret Instagram account, the one I'd found linked on Nathan's phone, had plenty to show me.

There were beautifully arranged pictures of her in pose after pose.

The newest had been taken at a restaurant by the ocean. Whoever sat across from her had been kept mostly out of the shot, but I recognized his tie clip. I'd given it to Nathan.

I looked lower in the picture. The ring on his left hand was missing.

A pale strip of skin showed where it should have been. It was impossible to miss.

He'd taken it off to be with her. I was the one at home believing in our engagement.

I drew in a breath and made myself hold back the tears.

Then, for reasons I couldn't explain, I went through every post on the account.

Sophie had joined Nathan's studio three years ago. Two months later, the posts about their relationship began.

There was far more between them than I'd suspected.

“He said taking the subway and the bus to work every day was wearing me out. So he rented me this amazing apartment downtown.”

My hand shook as I opened the location tag. She'd been living in my neighborhood.

Three years. They'd done this so close to me for three years, and I hadn't noticed.

“Told him I was hungry, and my favorite photographer left his girlfriend at home to come make chicken and dumplings for me. My favorite. So delicious!”

That one hurt in a different way.

I'd cooked for Nathan for eight years. I hadn't even known he could make a meal like that, much less that he'd do it for someone else.

“Finally saw the northern lights! He stayed outside with me for hours in the freezing cold until we got the perfect photo.”

I could hardly stand to look at it.

The view was gorgeous. So was Sophie.

He'd spent three years photographing her. He wouldn't give me so much as a snapshot on vacation.

I folded myself into a corner of the couch and cried. At some point, I started laughing, only to end up in tears again.

Under her latest picture, I typed a comment.

“Pretty sure your boyfriend is my fiancé. Didn't you know?”

Within moments, her quiet comment section filled with replies.

“She's been posting pics with this guy for years. He's someone else's fiancé?”

“How can people be this shameless? Gross.”

“If he's not taken, prove it. Show his face. Otherwise, delete the account.”

More comments appeared every time I looked.

I signed out. I was reaching to switch off my phone when Nathan called.

My hand was shaking as I answered.

“Claire, what have you done?”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter