Chapter 3
He shouted so loudly that I flinched.
“Sophie doesn't have parents. You're her best friend, the person she trusts more than anyone. How could you turn on her like this?”
I bit my lip and closed my eyes.
I remembered a school dance back in middle school. Everyone else had friends clustered around them, while Sophie sat by herself in a corner.
She looked so lonely that I went over and took the seat beside her.
After that, we did everything together.
In high school, a bully asked her out. When she refused, he and his friends cornered her.
I threw myself into the fight without stopping to think. Someone called the police. If they hadn't, I don't know how I would have gotten out of there.
Later, Sophie cried while she cleaned and bandaged my injuries. Her hands wouldn't stop trembling.
“Claire, I'm sorry. You got hurt because of me. I'm so sorry. I owe you for this.”
Her eyes were swollen from crying. Even through the pain, I managed a grin.
“Come on. Stop crying. I'm not dying.”
Nathan knew about my parents. They divorced when I was little, and each went on to have another family. Neither wanted me in their new life.
Sophie had become more than my best friend. She was family. After growing up side by side, I couldn't imagine replacing her with anyone.
Now I could hear her crying through Nathan's phone.
“Please don't be mad, Nathan. This is my fault. You and Claire need to talk things out.”
I couldn't hold it in anymore.
“Why, Sophie?” I screamed. “Why him? Of all people, why did you have to do this to me?”
Her sobs grew louder.
“I'm sorry, Claire. Nothing's happening between Nathan and me. It's my fault, but I never wanted to hurt you. You have to believe me. Please.”
Nathan interrupted, furious.
“What is wrong with you, Claire? Listen to yourself. You're being paranoid and jealous.”
Hearing him speak to me like that hurt more than I could bear.
I was shaking all over and bit my lip harder. I wouldn't let him hear me cry.
“Paranoid? You've been taking pictures of Sophie for three years, Nathan. Do you think I'm stupid? Or am I just the person you unload on whenever you feel like it?”
He went silent.
A long time passed before he answered.
“They're pictures. Why are you making such a big deal of this?
“You don't get to make everyone else miserable just because you are. This is your problem, Claire. You're difficult, and you're boring. It's no surprise your parents didn't want you.
“I've had enough. Believe whatever you like.”
He hung up. For a moment, it felt as if the floor had dropped out from under me.
Eight years ago, he'd held me and told me it hurt him to see how strong I always had to be. He'd promised to love me, to keep me safe, for the rest of our lives.
Now he was using the thing that hurt me most to punish me.
Thunder sounded outside. Then another crack, and another.
I went to the window and closed it. I wasn't going to let him back in, either.
Nathan returned the following evening.
When he walked through the door, I smelled a trace of floral perfume and saw the red mark on his neck.
He was allergic to that perfume. It gave him a rash, and he'd never wanted it anywhere near him.
Sophie loved wearing it, though. Apparently, that made the difference.
I couldn't help a bitter little smile.
“Have you finished your tantrum?” he demanded. “Do you realize your comment practically started a harassment campaign against Sophie?”
He dropped his keys on the entryway cabinet, still angry.
I kept sorting the things I intended to put in my suitcase. I didn't answer.
That only made him angrier.
“What are you doing, Claire? Do you think ignoring me will make me beg? If you're playing hard to get, this isn't going to work.”
I stood straight and looked at him.
“I'm not trying to play anything. And I don't need you to chase me.”
“Why are you acting like this? She considers you her best friend. Do you know how much she's cried? People are attacking her online. She has no parents, Claire. What if she hurts herself? How can you be so cruel?”
His face was as cold as his voice.
“Go online and tell them you only gave your side of the story. Tell them Sophie didn't do anything wrong.”
He said it as an order, stripped off his jacket, and tossed it onto the couch.
I looked at him, then down at the things in front of me.
“No.”
I turned toward the bedroom, but he caught my wrist.
“Then what do you want from me? I took some pictures. Sophie told you nothing happened. We're friends, that's all.”
I could barely take in what he was saying.
“Nathan,” I said, keeping my voice low and even. “I'll believe she didn't set out to hurt me. I'll even believe nothing physical has happened between you.
“That doesn't mean you haven't betrayed me.”
