Chapter 1
My girlfriend set me up on a blind date in front of all our friends.
They thought it was cruel to do that to a man who’d spent five years chasing her.
None of them knew we were already together.
“If anyone finds out we’re dating, it’s over,” Claire had told me.
I’d kept her secret, hoping one day she’d introduce me as her boyfriend.
Instead, she introduced me to another woman.
This time, I said yes.
Nathan's POV
For a few seconds, nobody said a word. My girlfriend, Claire Winslow, looked startled that I'd actually accepted her offer to set me up with someone else.
She frowned at me. There seemed to be a question on her mind, but she let it go. With our friends waiting for her to follow through, she forwarded the woman's contact information.
Then she called her. “Hey, you said your family's been on your case about getting married, right? I've got a blind date for you.
“His name's Nathan Carter. He earned his doctorate at a top university, and he's a senior researcher at our lab now. You should meet him and see how it goes.”
The woman was still thanking her when Claire wandered away.
If our mutual friend Sophie Lawson hadn't called her over, Claire would have stayed a good ten feet from me all evening. That was how she usually treated me around other people: as though I wasn't there.
The whiskey suddenly tasted harsh. I closed my hands into fists, trying not to let any of it show on my face.
Once Sophie heard I'd agreed to a blind date, she sent me a different woman's number.
“She's been asking me about you forever, and you always say no! She's a catch, Nate. At least meet her.”
Without thinking, I looked for Claire. She stood beside Daniel Foster, the boy she'd grown up loving, smiling at him. She didn't look my way again.
One of her friends caught our conversation and laughed. “Claire, we all know Nathan follows you around because he's into you. Setting him up with another woman? That's cold.”
“Seriously. He's bought us thousands of coffees just to impress you. Five years, and you still won't give the poor guy an answer.”
Daniel turned his wineglass slowly in his hand, then lifted an eyebrow at her.
“Don't tell me you've spent all this time waiting for me. You haven't exactly asked me out since I got back.”
Claire looked at him with a warmth I knew too well. “That's because I haven't put together a proper proposal yet, Dan. I'm not going to give you anything less than the best.”
He laughed at her flirtation. I could barely swallow.
When Claire and I had become a couple, there hadn't been a romantic declaration, let alone an elaborate proposal. She'd just asked, “Nathan, do you have feelings for me?”
By then, I'd been in love with her for three years. I nodded before she could finish asking.
“We can be together,” she said, “but we're keeping it private. If anyone finds out we're dating, it's over.”
I was so happy she'd said yes that I didn't stop to consider what the rest of it meant.
I believed she'd finally understood how much I cared. Given enough time, I thought, she'd be ready to let people know.
So I'd kept trying to make a place for myself among her friends, hoping she'd eventually introduce me as her boyfriend.
Instead, she'd offered me to another woman. Anything to make it clear I wasn't hers.
I managed a small, bitter smile.
Sophie watched me add the contact she'd sent and finally relaxed.
“Every time I tried to introduce you, you told me there was already someone you liked. But she's kept you hanging all these years. She still won't even say you're together.
“You should have moved on ages ago. Trust me. I think you'll be happy with this one.”
I looked down.
She was right. I'd waited far too long.
After a moment, Sophie glanced toward Claire and lowered her voice.
“The woman she suggested was Vanessa Hart, wasn't it? Don't waste your time.
“Vanessa gets around. She's even hired male escorts. Everybody knows her family's been pushing her to get married for the last couple of years. At this point, she'll take any man willing to say yes.”
As she turned to leave, Sophie muttered, “What on earth makes Claire think you two are a good match?”
The smile I'd been holding onto went stiff. Apparently, in Claire's mind, Vanessa and I had one thing in common: we were both desperate to find someone to marry.
Not long before, my family had asked when I planned to settle down. I'd messaged Claire about it.
I'd hoped she'd finally agree to tell people about us and come meet my parents. Instead, she'd left my messages unanswered and stayed away from home for a month.
If she wanted no place in my life, I was done trying to force a place in hers.
I left the gathering and put in a request to transfer away from Boston.
Then a message arrived from the woman Sophie had introduced me to.
“Would you like to meet tomorrow?”
