Chapter 2

Nathan's POV

Once we'd agreed on a time and a place, I checked Claire's latest post. She was posing with a group of friends, and Daniel stood in the middle of the picture.

The caption said, “My friends beside me. The one I love right across from me.”

The group chat filled with replies almost immediately.

“Look at you, Claire! Dan's finally home! Congratulations to the lovebirds for making it official!”

“Official? Since when has Claire being in love with Dan been a secret?”

“So where does that leave Nathan? Hasn't he been chasing her for five years?”

“Chasing her? He's a simp. With Dan back, why would she bother with him?”

“She had the whole proposal planned, ring and all, before Dan even got home. It's pretty clear who she wants.”

“Uh, isn't Nathan still in this chat? He can see what we're saying…”

A second later, I was removed.

I stared at the screen, sick with a hurt I couldn't put into words.

I'd worked so hard to belong with those people. I'd even kept asking Claire until she finally added me to the chat.

At first, I'd posted constantly, trying to get conversations going. Claire hadn't liked it.

“You don't have to send so many messages,” she'd told me with a frown. “They're not interested.”

After that, the chat had mostly gone quiet. When I asked, she said, “People have lives, Nathan. They're busy. They don't have time to sit around texting.”

Now I knew they did have time. They just talked somewhere I couldn't see.

I'd spent years waiting for her to acknowledge me, waiting for the romantic gesture she'd promised. Daniel only had to return, and she was ready to give him all of it.

I sat beside the river for a while, answering a few messages. Eventually, I went home.

Claire was outside the elevator when I stepped off it. Daniel was right behind her.

She stopped at the sight of me. Her expression closed off. “Nathan? What are you doing here?”

I started to say I lived there. Then I remembered her rule: nobody could know we shared an apartment.

She'd even set separate times for us to come and go so nobody would suspect anything. In five years at the same address, we'd never once left the building together.

Before I could answer, she spoke again, looking worried that Daniel might understand.

“Would you stop following me? You're going to make people think there's something going on.”

I stood there without a word.

My phone lit up. She'd sent a text while I was still in front of her.

“Don't come home right now. Daniel just got back, and he needs somewhere to stay. I've told him he can stay here for a while. Your things have been packed and sent to our other apartment in Cambridge. Go there for now.”

I turned toward the elevator. Behind me, Daniel asked who I was.

“Just a guy who's been pursuing me,” Claire said. “Apparently, he thinks it's okay to follow me home. Don't worry. You can stay. I'll speak to building security.”

The doors were almost shut when Daniel laughed.

“You haven't changed the door code in five years, Claire! It's still the date I left. I told you to wait five years—have you actually been counting the days?”

My hand stopped above the elevator button.

When I'd first moved in, learning that code had made me quietly happy. Claire wouldn't tell anyone we were together, but she'd used our anniversary to unlock her front door.

I'd taken it as proof that she cared, even if she didn't know how to say so.

Now I understood. The small comfort I'd held onto all those years hadn't been about me at all.

I made my way to the Cambridge apartment, every step an effort, and collected my things to move out.

Late that night, Claire sent another message. I still hadn't answered the first one.

“Please don't read too much into this, Nate. Daniel's just home, and I'm helping him as a friend. As for telling people about us, I need a little more time.”

I left it unanswered and unpinned her conversation.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter