Chapter 3

Claire spent the next three hours sending me messages. Some demanded to know who I was meeting. Others accused me of imagining things. Whatever excuse I came up with, she said, it wouldn't make her change her mind.

[Where would you go without me? Stop taking this out on Dylan. I'll promote you when the next opportunity comes up. I promise.]

While she was sending that, I was having dinner with the head of a team at an American company. He'd come all this way to meet me. After dinner, I booked my flight to the United States for the following week.

Our office group chat kept buzzing all night. People were sharing photos of Claire and Dylan on their “date.”

When Claire went to the movies with me, she was so careful that she'd buy tickets at opposite ends of the theater. I'd sit in the back row; she'd sit in the front. In these pictures, she and Dylan were side by side in a loveseat, leaning into each other where everyone could see.

[Horror movies scare me. I need someone beside me so I can feel safe.]

She'd probably seen everyone celebrating her supposed relationship with Dylan in the chat and decided she should explain herself to me.

I didn't answer.

…

The next morning, I knocked on her door.

“What are you doing here so early?” she asked, looking flustered as she let me see inside.

A pair of men's dress shoes sat neatly by the entrance.

“Ms. Bennett, the suit you picked out is perfect. It's exactly my style!”

The voice came from her bedroom. Dylan had spent another night at her house.

Two matching coffee mugs sat on the table, still steaming. Even the disposable cardboard container she'd used for an ashtray had been replaced with a proper, elegant one.

In the bedroom, Dylan was running his hand over the jacket she'd chosen for him. He was already wearing the custom tie. They looked like a couple settling into a lovely morning together. I was the visitor who'd arrived uninvited and spoiled it.

“The rain was awful last night, and Dylan lives so far away. I let him stay over.” Claire looked guilty as she reached for my hand. “He'll leave soon. Why don't we go somewhere this weekend? We could—”

“There's no need.”

I stepped inside and picked up a package near the door. It held the birthday present I'd gotten for her earlier.

“We're done, Claire. I'm only here to take back my gift.”

Her outstretched hand stopped. She looked up sharply.

“What are you talking about?”

“E-Ethan?” Dylan appeared behind her, holding his coffee. “I'm so sorry. I had no idea you two were dating.”

He glanced quickly at Claire, then took another step toward me.

“That explains why you wouldn't come to my birthday party. You must really hate me.” He pressed his lips together. “There's nothing going on between me and Ms. Bennett, Ethan. Please, let me explain—”

Before he could touch me, he let his mug slip. Coffee splashed all over my clothes.

“Dylan!”

Claire shoved me aside and grabbed his hand.

“Stay still. I'll get some burn cream!”

Three years together, and I'd never known she kept anything like that in her house.

When I'd burned myself on her kettle, she'd handed me a pair of thin disposable gloves instead.

“I live on my own. I don't keep that stuff around. Just run your hand under the faucet.”

Nothing in her house was ever allowed to suggest she had a boyfriend. But Dylan came along, and suddenly every rule she'd made was optional.

I looked down at the coffee stain, laughed bitterly, and turned to leave.

“Ethan!”

For the first time, Claire ran after me.

“Would you stop getting upset with me over every little thing? Dylan's like a younger brother to me. You're my boyfriend. I have to—”

The elevator doors closed on her words.

I didn't look back.

I was due to fly out the next week. I'd thought we might at least end things peacefully. Claire made sure we couldn't.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter