Chapter 1

My husband bet thirty thousand dollars that I’d come crawling back within seventy-two hours.

Then he gave Brooke my house key, my bedroom, and directions to my nightgowns.

Our friends cheered her on as she tried out being “Mrs. Whitmore.”

Nathan called it a joke.

I packed my things in the empty house my parents had left me.

For once, I had somewhere to live where nobody was betting on how much humiliation I could take.


When I walked out, Nathan stayed inside.

Our friends were still encouraging him behind me.

“Claire's taking it to a whole new level this year.”

“Don't cave too quickly, Nathan.”

He laughed. “She can't walk away from me. Three days, tops. She'll come back without me lifting a finger.”

That evening, he opened another bet in the group chat: $30,000 said I wouldn't make it past seventy-two hours.

To help make sure I cracked first, he registered Brooke's fingerprint on our front-door lock. Then he handed her the spare key—the one that had always belonged to me.

Brooke took a picture of it next to her breakfast and posted it to the chat. She was wearing my slippers.

“First day as Mrs. Whitmore.”

The replies came immediately.

“You should sleep in the primary bedroom tonight.”

“And shouldn't Mrs. Whitmore get to wear the wife's nightgown?”

Nathan did nothing to shut them down. He even gave Brooke directions. “Second shelf in her walk-in closet.”

I read that while unpacking in the little house my parents had left me. It had stood empty for years. There was dust along the windowsills, and rust was beginning to show on the faucets.

At least nobody in that house was making a contest out of replacing me as Nathan's wife.

The first year they played this game, I'd cried in front of everyone after Brooke walked away in my nightgown.

Nathan had held me for a long time, soothing me. He'd only wanted to find out whether I'd be jealous, he said. Then he'd promised, “This is the first and last time.”

Now Brooke was rifling through my closet, trying on outfit after outfit. She started a livestream so our friends could vote on which “Mrs. Whitmore” look suited her best.

She twirled in my silk nightgown. “What do you think of this one?”

Nathan, sitting next to her, looked up. “It's not as dull on you.”

Laughing comments filled the screen.

Someone asked where I was. Brooke immediately looked close to tears.

“Claire doesn't know how to take a joke. It's only a challenge. I'm helping Nathan out, that's all. I didn't think she'd get mad enough to move out. But we know she'll come back eventually.”

Nathan passed her a tissue. Then a message from him appeared on my phone.

“A marriage needs some excitement. You don't need to get this worked up over a joke. If you're serious about leaving, come get everything else.”

When I returned for my things, my fingerprint wouldn't unlock the door.

Brooke let me in, still wearing my nightgown and slippers.

The bed had been remade with her favorite pink sheets. My skincare products were piled in a cardboard box.

Our wedding portrait no longer hung over the bed. It leaned against the wall in a corner, with half my face hidden behind that box.

Nathan shoved the box toward me. “Walking out won't get you anywhere this time, Claire.”

Brooke worried her lower lip. “Maybe I should take the guest room.”

She didn't step out of the bedroom or make any attempt to move her things.

As expected, Nathan caught her arm. “Mrs. Whitmore gets this room.”

He gave me that familiar, amused look. I supposed he expected me to argue over the bed, or cry and demand to know which of us he loved.

I lifted the box instead. “Anything else I need to take?”

His smile disappeared for the first time.

He studied me for several seconds. When he spoke again, his voice was cold. “Quite a performance, Claire. We'll see how long you keep it going.”

I said nothing. I turned and shut the door behind me.

Next Chapter