Chapter 2

The Whitmores held a family dinner on Brooke's third day as “Mrs. Whitmore.”

Nathan's mother, Margaret Bennett, sent me the address. She told me to bring the antique bracelet handed down to the family's daughters-in-law.

She had slipped it onto my wrist on our wedding day.

Margaret had never thought I belonged in the family. If Nathan hadn't insisted on marrying me, that bracelet would never have been mine.

I remembered my first visit to the Whitmore estate. In front of everyone at the dinner table, Margaret had said that my family was ordinary and that I wasn't suitable for hers.

Nathan had taken my hand. “I love her. Nobody else has a say in who I marry.”

Remembering that now, I couldn't take it seriously anymore.

I held the bracelet's box a little tighter. If I was going to dinner, I could return it and be finished with it.

Brooke was in my regular chair when I arrived at the estate.

There wasn't a place setting for me. A staff member fetched another chair and squeezed it in at the end of the table.

Margaret smiled. “Brooke's Mrs. Whitmore for a few days. Naturally, she gets your seat. You're young, Claire. You shouldn't get so upset over a little thing like this.”

Nathan had also arranged the menu around Brooke.

I was severely allergic to peanuts. Seven years into our marriage, his family still put peanut desserts on the dinner table.

Early on, he would remind them about my allergy. Eventually, he stopped doing that and simply told me to watch what I ate.

Brooke couldn't stand cilantro. Whenever she joined them, the kitchen used none at all. If a stray leaf made it into her soup, Nathan ordered a fresh bowl.

“The smell makes her nauseous.”

At the previous year's dinner, she had taken my chair for the first time.

I'd left the table. Nathan had followed and wrapped his arms around me, insisting a chair meant nothing. “That spot will always be yours,” he'd promised.

This year, there wasn't even a chair for me beside him.

Before we gathered for the family photograph, Margaret glanced at my wrist. “Let Brooke wear the bracelet for a minute. It'll look nicer in the picture.”

Brooke waved a hand. “Oh, I couldn't.”

But she didn't draw her wrist back.

Nathan reached for my hand before I could answer. He pulled the bracelet off, scraping my skin hard enough to hurt. He inspected the bracelet for damage without checking my wrist.

Then he put it on Brooke.

“You'll have it back when the seven days are up. It's a bracelet, Claire. Don't turn it into a big thing.”

Brooke stood beside him for the photograph. His parents sat in front of them. I was pushed to the edge, almost beyond the frame.

When the photographer asked us to close the gaps, Nathan deliberately rested his hand on Brooke's waist. He looked at me to see what I'd do.

I spoke to Margaret instead. “She can have the bracelet.”

Margaret's smile stiffened. “We're playing a game. Must you spoil dinner and embarrass me in front of the family? You ought to know better.”

A relative who didn't understand what was happening later shared the photo in the family group chat.

“At last, everyone's together this year.”

The replies praised Nathan and Brooke as a couple. A few relatives wanted to know when the wedding would be.

Margaret made no effort to correct them. She added a heart reaction.

I looked at the chat I'd belonged to for seven years and left it without a word.

Nathan noticed right away. “Quite a performance, Claire. We'll see how long you keep it going.”

He thought I was waiting for him to back down. I was removing myself from the Whitmore family, one connection at a time.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter