Chapter 4

On Brooke's last day as “Mrs. Whitmore,” Nathan called me back to the house.

The week was over, he said. He would return the key, the bracelet, and my resignation papers himself. We also needed to settle the matter of our marriage.

Through the partly open front door, I could see the living room. It looked exactly as it did whenever Nathan ended the annual game: champagne, a cake, and confetti.

Photographs of me breaking down over the previous three years covered the walls. Below them were new bets on how quickly I would fold at the sight of the divorce agreement.

Brooke sat on the couch in my nightgown. Nathan was next to her.

Before I went inside, someone began teasing them.

“You're clearly crazy about each other. Claire isn't here. Why not make the most of it?”

“Seriously. She always backs down after her little tantrum. You don't have to keep up the act. I saw you coming out of a hotel together on the sixteenth last month. You both had marks on your necks.

“And you still expect us to believe you're only friends?”

I stopped outside the doorway.

On the sixteenth, my stomach had hurt so badly that I could hardly stand. I'd called Nathan three times.

He'd said he couldn't leave a meeting. I should take some medicine, and if it got worse, get myself to a hospital.

He hadn't been tied up at work. He'd been in a hotel with Brooke.

Inside, she glanced at him. When he didn't respond, she caught his tie, rose onto her toes, and kissed him.

He let her.

Only after she drew back did he frown, as though he had remembered something.

“Claire's getting carried away,” he said, more soberly. “Maybe this should be the last year we do this.”

I nearly laughed. Even an affair could apparently be excused as part of the fun.

I took a breath and pushed the door open. The jokes stopped as I entered, though the room still held the awkward excitement of their kiss.

The divorce agreement lay at the center of the coffee table.

Nathan seemed uncomfortable when he saw me. Still, he wore the confidence of a man who expected the same outcome as every other year.

Someone laughed. “Remember two years ago, Claire? You were crying too hard to write your name on the fake divorce papers. Don't get this set wet.”

Brooke spoke gently. “It's nothing to get upset about. He only wants to know you love him.”

Nathan settled back against the couch. “Admit you're jealous, say sorry to Brooke, and put your ring on again. I'll rip these papers up.”

I opened the agreement.

The division of assets was genuine. So were the property provisions. It had our actual marriage details and his attorney's signed approval.

To make the threat convincing, Nathan had commissioned a real settlement agreement. He still hadn't imagined that I might accept it.

One of his friends was filming, ready to capture my fourth collapse.

They began counting down. Before they finished, I reached for the pen.

Nathan was smiling already. I imagined he expected me to cry as I had two years earlier and ask whether he truly wanted to leave me.

I didn't protest. I didn't cry. I wrote my name carefully on the signature line.

All the laughter cut off.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter