Chapter 1

My wife bet $4,500 that I’d come begging to return within seventy-two hours.

To help herself win, she gave Evan my house keys, my car, and our bedroom.

Their friends called him the substitute husband.

Claire called it harmless excitement.

When I came back for my belongings, she waited for me to lose my temper.

I picked up the box instead.

Then I took off my wedding ring and left it beside her.


Nathan's POV

My wife, Claire Whitmore, didn't follow me when I walked out of our house.

Behind me, her friends were still laughing and calling out encouragement.

“Nathan's really stepping it up this year!”

“Don't give in already, Claire!”

She gave a quiet laugh. “He can't last without me. Give him three days. He'll come begging to come home.”

That night, Claire opened another betting pool in their group chat. She put up $4,500, wagering that I'd fold within seventy-two hours.

She also added her best friend Evan Mercer's fingerprint to our smart lock and gave him a set of house keys. She wanted him to look like he belonged there, hoping that would make me surrender first.

Evan posted a picture of the keys beside his breakfast. My slippers were on his feet at the bottom of the shot. His caption read, “One Week as the Substitute Husband: Day 1.”

Their friends couldn't get enough of it.

“Think you can claim the primary bedroom tonight, Evan?”

“Shouldn't he get Nathan's car, too? He's filling in as Claire's husband, after all.”

Claire didn't tell them to stop. She answered, “The car key's on the second shelf by the front door.”

I saw the post while unpacking at the little house my parents had left me. No one had lived there in years. Dust lined the windowsills, and rust had started to stain the faucets. Still, nobody in that house considered my place in their life a party game.

The first year they did this, Evan took one of my tailored suits. I blew up in front of everyone. Claire came after me and spent ages talking me down. She said she only wanted to see whether I cared enough to be jealous.

“It won't happen again, Nathan,” she promised.

Now Evan was in our walk-in closet, pulling out my suits and trying them on.

He found my watches and cufflinks, too. Then he went live so his friends could help dress him for his new role as Claire's husband. Facing the camera, he fastened a cufflink and straightened his collar.

“What do you think of this one?”

Claire sat nearby. She glanced up. “You wear it better than Nathan does.”

Laughter filled the livestream.

Then somebody asked why I hadn't shown up.

Evan settled back against the couch and gave an apologetic-looking smile. “Nathan gets offended over everything. It's just a game. I was doing Claire a favor, and he got so worked up he moved out. He'll be back, though. We all know that.”

“Once he's finished sulking,” Claire added.

Then she texted me. “You know a relationship needs a little excitement. Don't lose your mind over a harmless joke, Nathan. If you're going to keep threatening to leave, come get the rest of your things.”

When I returned for them, the lock wouldn't accept my fingerprint. Evan had to let me in. He wore my watch, and my slippers slapped against the floor as he walked.

The bed in the primary bedroom now had the pale blue sheets he liked. My toiletries had been thrown into a cardboard box.

Our wedding picture was off the wall, leaning in a corner. The box obscured half of each of our faces.

Claire slid the box toward me. “This whole hard-to-get routine only works once, Nathan.”

Evan rested against the bedroom doorframe. “Should I take the guest room, Claire?”

He asked without making any move to pack or leave.

“No. You're the substitute husband. Of course you get the main bedroom.”

Then she looked at me, amused in the same familiar way. She was waiting for me to explode, drag Evan out, or demand that she choose between us in front of an audience.

Instead, I lifted the box. “Is that all of it?”

For the first time, her smile slipped. She studied me for several seconds.

“You're making this look pretty real, Nathan. Let's see how long you last.”

I didn't answer. Before leaving, I took off my wedding band and set it beside her. Then I turned and shut the door behind me.

Next Chapter