Chapter 4

On the last day of the substitute-husband week, Claire called me back to the house.

The seven days were up, she said. She'd personally hand back my keys, the signet ring, and the resignation papers. Then we'd finally settle what was happening between us.

Before I went inside, I could see through the partly open door. The living room had the same end-of-game decorations as every other year: champagne, a cake, and streamers.

Pictures covered the walls. They showed me arguing, storming out, and tearing up their fake agreements over the previous three years.

Under the pictures, they'd written this year's bets. How many minutes would I last after seeing the divorce papers?

Evan occupied my usual spot on the couch. He twirled my car keys around a finger. The Whitmore ring was still on his right hand, and Claire stood beside him.

Someone called out, laughing, “Nathan's not here yet. Why don't you two admit what's really going on?”

“Seriously. He throws a fit and then comes back every time. Why keep pretending? I saw you leaving a hotel together on the sixteenth last month. Your collars didn't even hide the hickeys. And you're still saying you're just best friends?”

Outside the door, I stopped with my hand on the handle. I remembered the sixteenth. My stomach had hurt so badly I couldn't stand upright. I called Claire three times before she answered.

She said she was in a meeting and couldn't get away. Take something for it, she'd told me. If it got too bad, I could go to the hospital alone.

She hadn't been working. She'd been at a hotel with Evan.

He glanced at her. When she didn't object, he stood, slipped an arm around her waist, and kissed her.

She didn't push him off. Only after he stepped back did she frown, as though something had occurred to her.

“Nathan's taken it too far this year. We shouldn't do these games anymore.”

I almost laughed. Apparently even sleeping with someone else could be excused as part of a game.

I drew a breath, pushed the door open, and entered.

Their laughter stopped. Nobody had time to hide the closeness I'd just seen, and the room felt tense with it.

The divorce settlement sat in the middle of the coffee table. Claire looked uneasy, but she was still more certain than worried. Three years had taught her that I'd always back down.

Someone laughed into the silence. “Remember two years ago, Nathan? You started signing, then tore up the fake papers halfway through. Don't lose your nerve this time!”

Evan spoke as though we were discussing nothing important. “Don't get so upset. Claire only wanted to know you still loved her.”

She leaned against the couch, fully confident.

“Tell me you're jealous, apologize to Evan, and put your wedding ring back on. Then I'll tear up the agreement, Nathan.”

I read through it. The assets were real. So were the property descriptions and the details of our marriage. Her lawyer had prepared the document for actual use, not another mock performance.

She'd brought in real divorce papers to frighten me, certain I'd never sign them. A friend had their phone ready to record my reaction. This would be the fourth year they filmed me falling apart in front of everyone.

I picked up the pen before their countdown ended. Claire began to smile. She must have expected me to shove the papers aside, as I had two years earlier, and demand to know whether she meant it.

I didn't challenge her or stop to reconsider. I signed the last page slowly, making every letter clear.

The laughter cut off.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter