Chapter 1

My sister was driving when the car hit an older man.

I told the police it was me.

Back then, my family promised they would never forget what I’d done for her.

Years later, Caroline was ashamed to have me as her brother.

They remembered the accusation.

Somehow, they had forgotten whose hands were on the wheel.


I returned to my bedroom. Nothing had moved. On the desk, my college acceptance letter had faded to yellow.

There had been a time when I made my family proud.

Our family picture still hung on the wall. I was smiling in it, so sure of the future waiting for me. My sister, Caroline Bennett, leaned against my side and grinned at the camera.

That was the year she got her license. She'd been so excited about her new car that she'd insisted on taking me for a drive.

A cat ran out into the street. Caroline jerked the wheel to miss it, and the car struck an older man crossing the road. She started shaking. She couldn't stop.

I looked at her white face and the tears running down it. Then I called the police, keeping my voice steady.

“I was driving. I hit him.”

I let them put everything on me. My sister was just starting her life. I couldn't bear to see it end before she'd had a chance to live it.

And my life? I hadn't thought about that.

I lifted the photograph off its hook. Dampness had loosened the glass in the frame.

When I pressed against it, it broke with a sharp snap.

I took a jagged piece and brought it to my wrist. In my head, Caroline was crying again. I could see our parents kneeling until their knees bled, hear all the things they'd sworn to me.

None of those promises had lasted.

I shut my eyes and cut. Blood fell across the letter on my desk.

My strength was leaving me. So was the warmth. I couldn't stop feeling cold.

I folded onto the floor and hugged my arms around myself. Tears ran down my face.

And still, beneath everything else, I felt relief.

Caroline wouldn't have to be ashamed of her brother anymore. No one could keep pointing at her and saying she had a murderer in the family. Mom and Dad wouldn't have to face those looks on my account.

They could begin again without me. I wouldn't have to endure my illness or see the disappointment in their faces.

Fireworks sounded somewhere outside.

Thanksgiving. I'd almost forgotten. The day everyone was supposed to be together.

Mom. Dad. Caroline. I hope you get to spend many more Thanksgivings together. I'm going now. I won't trouble you again.

But even then, if I could have returned to that day in the car, I knew what I would have done. After the crash, I would still have moved Caroline aside, sat behind the wheel, and taken the blame.

Next Chapter