Chapter 2

When I opened my eyes, I was hanging in the air.

I'd expected my family to have left, still furious with me. Instead, all three of them were crowded into the cramped hallway.

Dad crouched against a corner and smoked. As soon as he finished one cigarette, he lit another. The floor around his shoes was littered with butts.

Mom stood against the wall. She was shaking, crying without making a sound.

Caroline sat on the stairs with her face buried against her knees. Her shoulders kept moving as she sobbed.

For a long time, nobody said anything. Finally, Dad broke the silence.

“Was I… too hard on him?” His voice was rough.

Caroline lifted her head sharply. Her cheeks were wet.

“Dad, how could you talk to Nathan like that? He just came home. He's still sick!”

Mom began crying aloud.

“I did this. I should never have said any of it!” She struck her own cheek. “What was I thinking? After everything Nate went through in prison, how could I say those things to him?”

She beat a hand against her chest. “What kind of mother am I?”

Dad grabbed her wrist. His eyes were red.

“Don't. Please, stop. We were all worn down. Everything we had went into trying to help him with the case. Our savings, all of it. Then we borrowed more.

“We couldn't leave the house without thinking someone was staring. When we stayed home, we worried about what might be happening to him in there. I was just… I couldn't take any more.”

He sounded smaller than I'd ever heard him.

“I'm his father. I should've protected him. Instead, I made him pay for how angry I was.”

Caroline shook her head, still crying.

“It wasn't you. It was me. He wouldn't have been in prison if it weren't for me. None of this would've happened to us.”

Suddenly, she stood.

“I need to tell him I'm sorry. He needs to know we didn't mean what we said.”

She started toward my bedroom.

I reached for her before I even thought about it.

Don't open it. Please, Carrie. Don't come in.

My hand passed through her arm.

I looked down. I could see through myself. Beneath my feet, there wasn't a shadow.

I was dead already. Nothing hurt anymore. And there was nothing I could do to keep them out.

Caroline reached for the knob, but Mom caught her.

“Wait.”

Mom dried her cheeks. She was trying to make herself sound firm.

“Give him a little space. He's too hurt to hear us right now. Let's pick something up from that restaurant he likes. When he's had time to settle down, we can tell him we're sorry.”

Dad crushed out his cigarette and got up.

“And a bottle of good wine. We'll make a fresh start.”

So they hadn't hated me. They'd been frightened and exhausted, and I'd been the person standing in front of them.

I followed as they went downstairs, leaning on one another.

I felt as though I might choke.

If only I could tell them. I hadn't held any of it against them. I knew how hard those years had been, how tired they'd become. I'd thought leaving would spare them more of that.

They wouldn't have to worry about me now.

…

At the mall, they went into a jewelry store before they went anywhere else.

Mom pointed through the glass at a gold chain.

“That one, David.”

Dad looked at the price and frowned.

“We can't afford—”

“It's for Nate.” She didn't let him finish. “We had nothing for him when he got home. Not even a little present. And then we treated him like that.

“He's always been good to us. Even as a little boy, he'd give Carrie anything before keeping it for himself. After all he's done, we owe him this much. It can be his birthday gift.”

Caroline took a few wrinkled bills out of her wallet and pushed them into Dad's hand.

“It's from my part-time job. I know it isn't much. But I want to put something in.”

Dad looked from my mother to my sister. At last, he nodded.

“We'll buy it,” he told the clerk. “Could you put it in a gift box?”

They never got to the restaurant. Every dollar they'd brought went toward that necklace.

I watched them carry the little box away, unable to sort through what I was feeling.

They'd given me everything they had left. And all I could think was that I'd failed them—as a son and as a brother. I was the reason they'd lost so much.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter