Chapter 3

It was dark when they came home. They brought the small gift box inside, smiling a little, as if they finally had a way to say what they hadn't been able to say before.

Dad set it in the center of the dining table.

“We'll give it to Nate when he comes out,” he said quietly. “I think he'll like it.”

Mom nodded and went straight into the kitchen to start dinner.

“I'll make spaghetti. His favorite. Maybe it'll be a good way to start over. I just want things to get better for us.”

Caroline went after her.

“I'll do the salad, Mom.”

They talked softly as they worked. The kitchen lights made the house feel warm again.

In the living room, Dad found a clean towel and started wiping my bedroom door. He worked slowly, pressing hard, going over the same spots. Years of dust came away. He kept wiping, as if doing this small thing might help him reach me.

I hovered near his shoulder. There was gray at his temples that hadn't been there before prison. His eyes had more lines around them.

I'm sorry, Dad. You wanted so much for me. I couldn't give you any of it. All I did was make your life harder.

Mom came out with a plate of hot spaghetti.

“David, tell him it's ready.”

Dad put the towel down and approached my door. He lifted a hand, then stood there without knocking.

At last, he drew a breath.

“Nate? Come have dinner. I shouldn't have said what I did. I know that. Please… don't believe those things. I was wrong.”

He was almost begging.

There was no sound from my room.

He waited, his face changing. Caroline came to stand beside him.

“Please, Nate. Come out. We don't want you to be upset with us.”

Nothing.

Mom began to cry again.

“How long is he going to shut us out?”

She came up to the door and knocked hard.

“Nathan Bennett! What else do you want us to do? We said we were wrong! Do we have to cut our hearts out before you'll listen?

“Open this door. Whatever it is, just come out and talk to us!”

Her voice broke. She sounded angry, but fear was creeping into it too. She didn't know how to make me answer.

Dad took her arm.

“Let him be for now. We hurt him. He needs time.”

He took a key from his pocket and handed it to Caroline.

“Here's the spare for his room, Carrie. Keep it with you. When he's ready, he'll come out.”

Dad still believed I was angry. He didn't know that no amount of waiting would bring an answer.

Caroline closed her fingers around the key.

…

They sat down together, but nobody ate. The steam rose from my spaghetti and slowly disappeared. Behind the bedroom door, my body was cooling too.

Finally, Dad sighed. He picked up my plate and carried it down the hall.

“You must be hungry, Nate. Be mad at me if you need to, but please eat something.”

He lowered the plate to the floor, taking care not to spill it.

“It's here by the door. You can get it whenever you want. We'll leave you alone.”

Then he took Mom and Caroline away.

I knelt in front of the plate. The spaghetti was cold by then. I looked at it and cried.

At least they didn't have to look after me anymore. I kept telling myself that the three of them could finally have some peace.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter