Chapter 4
Someone knocked hard at the front door early the next morning.
Dad hurried out, thinking I'd finally left my room. But the person at the entrance was a middle-aged man in a neatly pressed suit.
“Is this the Bennett home? I'm here to see Nathan.”
Dad stopped.
“I'm his father. Who are you?”
The man opened his briefcase, took out a business card, and offered it to him.
“Martin Hale. I was Nathan's lawyer.”
I floated behind Dad, wondering what he wanted. My case was over. Why had he come now?
Dad asked him in. Hearing them, Mom and Caroline came out of their bedrooms.
Mr. Hale didn't waste any time.
“I have some encouraging news. The family of the man who died has been in touch. They want to give us a written statement supporting a review of Nathan's conviction. They don't want him to keep carrying the full blame.”
My parents and sister stared at him.
“Why?” Dad asked, barely getting the word out.
“The man was seriously ill before the accident. His doctors had already told the family he had very little time. They've now shared information indicating that his underlying illness was the main cause of his death. The collision contributed, but the original case didn't tell the whole story.
“His family has struggled with that for years. They feel Nathan paid too high a price, especially when he was so young.
“Their statement and that medical information give us a basis to ask the court to review the case. I can't guarantee we'll get the conviction thrown out. But we may be able to correct the record. That would give him a better chance at work, at rebuilding his life.”
After so long, someone was offering them a possibility other than more bad news.
Dad couldn't hold his mouth steady. He took Mr. Hale's hand in both of his.
“Thank you. God, thank you.”
Mom and Caroline began crying, but this time they were smiling too.
“He can start again,” Mom said. “Thank God. Our boy can start again.”
She dried her face and hurried down the hall.
“I have to tell him. He needs to hear this!”
She pounded on my door.
“Nate! Open up! We've got good news. They can help you. You might not have to live with this conviction forever!”
No answer came.
Dad's smile disappeared. He looked toward my room, and this time he didn't tell anyone to wait.
“Carrie! Where's the key? Open the door!”
Caroline dug into her pocket. Her hands shook so badly that she couldn't get the key into the lock. She tried again.
The lock clicked.
Sunlight fell through the window across the untidy room. It caught the dried, dark blood on the floor.
My body lay in it. Beside my hand was the college letter, soaked red.
The room smelled of blood.
Caroline screamed.
“Nate!”
