Chapter 1

I died while my family celebrated my sister’s eighteenth birthday.

Nora thought she’d heard me calling for help.

“Couldn’t we stop the party and look for her?”

Mom kept stroking her cheek.

“It’s your birthday. Nothing else matters today.”

I stood beside them, weightless, and reached to wipe Nora’s tears.

My fingers passed through her face.

Even now, my parents thought I was somewhere causing trouble.


The pain burned through me. Then, suddenly, I couldn't feel my own weight.

My family was sitting around my sister, celebrating her birthday.

“Nora, sweetheart, you're eighteen. Go on—make a wish and blow out your candles.”

She was wearing a formal gown, with an elaborate cake stacked eighteen tiers high in front of her.

She didn't look happy. After hesitating, she asked, “Where's Clara? Why hasn't she come? Is she mad at me?”

Mom looked away. “The Bellandis are stirring up trouble again, honey. Clara's taking care of it.

“You'll be leaving tomorrow. Spend a little time with us while you can.”

That was when Nora started crying.

She hugged our parents, barely able to get the words out.

“I don't want to leave you. I don't want to leave Clara, either.”

Watching her hurt.

I tried to brush the tears off her cheek. My fingers went straight through.

For years, I'd wondered what that signet ring had done to our parents. Everything had changed after Nora took it.

Their devotion to her had become boundless and impossible to reason with.

If they thought she wanted something, I had to surrender it. They never hesitated.

Once, Nora glanced a second time at a dress I loved. Mom immediately told me to give it to her.

Nora kept insisting she didn't want it. That made no difference.

Another time, she said blood frightened her. I was put through vicious training so I could stay close and protect her whenever she needed me.

I'd fallen in love, too. But with Nora promised to the Bellandi family, my own marriage couldn't be mine to choose.

Our parents worried my happiness would upset her. They made me break things off with Owen.

I cried as I told him it was over. He wouldn't accept it. While driving to see me, he went off the road.

When I demanded answers from our parents, they fell back on the words they always used: “You owe your sister.”

Because I owed her, I had to surrender everything I cared about—my possessions, my future, the man I loved. Finally, my life.

Eventually, Nora was all my world consisted of.

After I argued with our parents, she'd cry, then slip my favorite dress back into my closet.

She refused to eat until they agreed to ease up on my training. She carried messages between Owen and me behind their backs.

My unhappiness always made her cry. It was making her cry now.

Still, she persisted. “Mom, I heard Clara just now. I think she was calling for help.

“Couldn't we stop the party and look for her...”

“That's enough!”

Mom kept caressing Nora's cheek, her own eyes turning red.

“It's your birthday. Nothing else matters today. Don't you remember? She's always resented how much we love you. She's always causing trouble. Especially when you were sick, and she...”

Everyone at the table fell quiet.

Looking at my sister's pale face, I felt the old guilt return.

Nora had been eleven when she got a bad case of pneumonia.

By then, I was living at the training camp. I was allowed home only once a week.

The work was punishing. Most days, I had bruises and open cuts all over me.

That day, I'd limped home exhausted and sore to find our parents hovering over her bed.

They were helping her drink water, treating her as gently as if she might break.

Neither of them had ever looked at me with that kind of tenderness.

Years of resentment came up before I could stop them.

I rushed at Mom and smacked the cup from her hand.

Warm water hit Nora's white face and soaked into her hair.

She didn't dodge. She only stared at me, her eyes wet.

“Quit the act!

“You have pneumonia. Does that mean everyone has to worship you? I bleed every single day at that camp. Have any of you ever bothered to look at me?”

Dad got out of his chair and advanced on me with his hand raised.

“Clara, what the hell is wrong with you? That's your sister!”

“My sister?”

I laughed, but the sound broke as I started crying.

“She's the one you call your daughter! What does that make me? A dog you trained to catch her bullets? She gets my future, and now she gets the only love I've ever suffered for!”

Dad didn't hit me. Somehow, the coldness in his stare felt worse.

Mom pulled Nora against her chest and pointed at me, her eyes red. “How did you turn into this? She agreed to a marriage that would kill her so you wouldn't have to! Is it so wrong for us to love her a little more? And you're doing this while she's sick?”

I stared at them, feeling suddenly cold. “If she's the only daughter you want, why do you bother keeping me?”

I spun around and ran. Nora's tearful voice followed me to the door. “Clara, wait! Please don't go! Mom, Dad, it isn't her fault...”

I kept running without knowing where I was going. Eventually, I found myself alone in an alley.

I sank against the wall. Training had left my whole body aching, but the hurt inside was worse.

Then I heard stumbling steps and a muffled cough.

Nora had followed me.

She wasn't wearing shoes. Each step looked like a struggle. Her face brightened when she spotted me, just before she bent over coughing.

“What are you doing out here?”

I tried to get up. My injured leg buckled, dropping me back to the ground.

Without answering, she crouched slowly at my side. From her pajama pocket, she took a bottle of liniment and fresh gauze.

She eased up my pant leg and gently rubbed the liniment onto my skin.

“Does it... hurt?”

Cold sweat dotted her forehead. The anger I'd felt toward her disappeared, leaving me ashamed. None of this had been her fault.

“You're an idiot.” My voice broke. I went to touch her cheek, saw the dirt on my hands, and stopped. “Get home. Being out here will make you worse!”

She shook her head and kept going until she'd bandaged my leg. Then she rested against my shoulder.

“They said you won't have to go to camp as much anymore. Come home, Clara. Please.”

I couldn't move.

She'd known.

She understood everything that had been hurting me. She didn't know how to fix it, but she was trying in the only ways she could.

“When I'm eighteen, after I leave...”

She couldn't finish. She pressed her face into my neck, and her hot tears made me flinch.

“You'll be all Mom and Dad have. Be good to yourself. And love them for me, okay...”

I put my arms around her small, thin body and held her close.

After that, I quit protesting. If she needed a shadow, a shield, I would be both.

I kept thinking that if I obeyed and gave enough away, our parents might someday look at me the way they looked at her.

They never did. Until my last day, they watched me as though I couldn't be trusted.

I knew they believed jealousy had taken over my life.

Once, it had.

Now even that was gone. It had died when I did.

If losing me meant Nora could escape that marriage and live for herself, at least my life would have counted for something.

There was just one thing I couldn't let go of. I'd spent my entire life wanting their love, and I still didn't have it. Not even in death.

Next Chapter