Chapter 1

On graduation day, my father called a friend to help my twin sister find a job.

For me, he had a warning: don’t expect much with such a specialized degree.

My boyfriend offered to find me a receptionist position.

I was still wearing my gown when I opened the offer on my phone.

Aerospace materials research. Excellent pay. Seattle.

I’d spent a week waiting for someone to ask about my future.

With six hours left to decide, I stopped waiting.


Owen erased the picture, then returned Sophie's phone.

“Check the others too. Get rid of whichever ones you don't like.”

She hadn't reached the photo album when an email banner slid across the screen.

Thank you for applying. Following a careful review...

Another rejection.

Tears sprang into Sophie's eyes.

“Maybe there's something wrong with me,” she murmured. “I've sent out so many applications. No one wants to hire me.”

Mom wrapped her arms around her.

“Don't say that. You've done everything you should. It's a terrible time to be looking for work.”

Then she looked over at me.

“Claire picked such a narrow field that we knew finding a job would be hard for her. You have exactly the kind of personality employers want. That recruiter obviously has no judgment.”

I was standing a few feet from them, my graduation gown still on.

I hadn't spoken.

That hadn't kept them from using me, again, to reassure Sophie.

For a long time, I'd wondered if she was their real daughter and I wasn't.

But we were twins.

Our dark hair, gray eyes, and almost indistinguishable faces made the family resemblance impossible to miss. We didn't need a DNA test.

I kept looking for a reason anyway.

Perhaps loving me took more effort.

Perhaps I wasn't clever enough, agreeable enough, or likable enough.

I tried harder. I quit protesting. I learned to be the daughter who made no demands and needed no rescuing.

Eventually, I had a record of accomplishments they could have been proud of. That was when I understood.

It wasn't a question of what Sophie had earned.

Putting her first was what they were used to doing.

Ignoring me was just as familiar.

Owen spoke softly to her while Dad moved aside to make a call.

He dialed a college friend in human resources at Northstar Technologies.

“Grant, how are you? Robert Whitaker here,” he said, all warmth. “My daughter has just finished college. Would you mind looking over her résumé?”

Within minutes, he was putting his phone away, pleased with himself.

“Email me your résumé this evening, Sophie. Grant will get it to the appropriate hiring manager. The first step in your career is important. There's no reason you should end up at some obscure little company.”

There was always someone ready to keep Sophie from falling.

The slightest trouble brought everyone to her side.

Freshman year, she failed a mandatory economics class.

Mom hired a senior in her department to tutor her for $150 an hour and prepaid for twenty appointments.

That semester, I got the top grade in a materials engineering class.

I sent Mom a screenshot. I wanted to hear that I'd done well.

She called instead.

“Sophie just told us she failed her midterm. Was today really the day to send us your grade?”

“I didn't know she'd failed.”

“You're her sister, Claire. Be a little more considerate. You don't have to turn everything into a contest.”

I never sent her another grade.

In junior year, I went down outside the engineering building, doubled over with pain. I could hardly get to my feet.

I called Owen.

I'd never needed him to come help me before. This time, I only wanted him to drive me to the ER.

For a moment, he said nothing.

“Sophie has to give a presentation tomorrow,” he said at last. “She's panicking. I said I'd go through it with her.”

I held my stomach and tried to catch my breath.

“Owen, I can't even walk.”

“Claire, you always manage on your own. Could you get an Uber? I'll call and see how you're doing later.”

When we reached the hospital, my Uber driver saw how pale I was. He got out, helped me from the car, and walked me into the emergency department. He waited until a nurse arrived with a wheelchair.

A man who didn't know me had seen that I needed someone.

My own boyfriend had left me to cope.

Maybe I'd spent too many years being the capable one.

They were so accustomed to my silence that they no longer imagined I could be hurt.

Much later, Mom thought to ask what I was going to do.

“Have you started applying for jobs, Claire?”

Before I could answer, Dad dismissed the subject with a wave.

“She'll find something. She can't expect much straight out of school with such a specialized degree.”

Lucas looked my way.

“Don't be too choosy. You don't want to still be living at home in six months.”

Owen offered to find out whether his employer needed a receptionist.

He meant it kindly. He seemed to think he'd given my future real consideration.

I looked down at my phone and opened my offer.

Rainier Advanced Materials Institute

Aerospace Materials Program — Seattle, Washington

It was a respected position, with pay beyond anything I'd let myself hope for. The work was precisely what I'd studied for those past four years.

And it was almost three thousand miles from my family.

For a week, I'd left the offer unsigned.

I'd called it taking time to decide.

What I'd really been doing was waiting.

For Mom to ask where I wanted to go.

For Dad to talk through my options with me, as he'd done for Sophie.

For Owen to recall our promise to live in the same city when we graduated.

The deadline was six hours away. None of them had asked.

They'd already assumed I had nothing worth discussing.

I tapped Accept.

A confirmation filled the screen.

Welcome to Rainier, Claire Whitaker. We're delighted you're joining us.

Your start date at our Seattle campus is in three days.

Well, there it was.

My first genuine welcome on graduation day had come from the other side of the country.

I looked at my family, happily clustered around Sophie. Nothing about the group suggested anyone was missing.

I reserved a seat on a flight to Seattle three days later.

Next Chapter