Chapter 5: The Eighteenth Time, and Yes, It Was Lightning

POV: Elena

Lucas stopped walking.

"After this reunion is over," he said, voice completely flat, like he was reading off a weather report, "we're done. No more of whatever this is."

My throat tightened.

There was so much I wanted to say. About the hallway. About the trash can. About the sound something made inside my chest when I watched him drop that letter without even reading it all the way through.

What came out was: "Who said I still like you? Don't flatter yourself."

Steadier than I expected.

Lucas's expression shifted — something complicated moving behind his eyes, his lips parting like there was more coming —

The sky exploded.

A bolt of white split the entire length of Broadway, and the thunder hit almost simultaneously, so loud it locked every muscle in my body. My ears rang. The air smelled like burning.

Lucas reached toward me instinctively.

Then pulled his hand back.

The rain came down all at once. Not drizzle — the kind of summer downpour that soaks you in three seconds flat. I ran toward the nearest tree on instinct, pressing my back against the trunk, shielding my face with both arms.

Then.

A bolt of lightning drove straight down the tree.

No fucking way.

The current tore through me from the soles of my feet to the top of my skull — total, complete paralysis. My heart seized like someone had grabbed it with both hands and twisted.

Everything went black.

Eighteen.

Red brick under my knees.

That one loose tile.

I was on the arch pathway in Greenwich Village, thighs shaking violently, stomach turning itself inside out. I bent forward and dryheaved, ears still screaming, my mind cycling through exactly three words on a loop —

Numb. Pain. Black.

Getting struck by lightning is so much worse than getting hit by a truck. A truck is bluntforce impact — fast, direct, lights out. Lightning is a fullsystem burn from the inside. Every nerve fires at once, and then keeps firing even after you're already dead.

Footsteps approached.

A hand landed on my back.

"Elena —"

I slapped it away hard.

"Don't touch me!"

Lucas's hand froze in midair.

I saw Lucas freeze for a moment, then quietly pulled his hand back. “It seems the time of death wasn’t exactly one o’clock. I made a wrong judgment.”

Lucas paused for a second and went on. “This is already the eighteenth time. We’re back at this intersection again. Maybe it’s not about the time at all. Instead, there’s a key event that triggers your death, just like the death trigger conditions in an infinite game…”

Right now, though, I had no desire to listen to Lucas’s elaborate rational analysis. All I wanted to do was roll my eyes at him.

I looked up. He was crouched in front of me, something in his face that wasn't quite concern and wasn't quite the usual detachment either — more like something being held down by force.

I didn't have space for that right now.

I stood. My legs were still shaking. I pulled a breath in, turned, and walked.

Red light.

I stepped onto the crosswalk anyway.

Steady pace. Didn't look at the signal.

It resets either way.

Tires screamed against pavement — a flatbed truck braking so hard the whole cab shuddered, the driver leaning out the window with a stream of profanity loud enough to carry half a block.

I stopped in the middle of the crosswalk.

No. I can't do this.

I made myself breathe. Stepped back to the curb.

The driver was still yelling. I walked to his window and grabbed the door frame with both hands.

"Do you remember?" My voice was shaking. "You've hit me — more than once. Do you remember any of it?!"

He stared at me like I'd crawled out of somewhere that had padded walls.

"Get the hell away from my truck."

The window went up.

Lucas was already there, pulling me back by the arm.

"He doesn't know," he said quietly. "In this loop, it's only you and me."

The truck pulled away.

I stood there watching it disappear around the corner, and something inside my chest just — gave out.

I crouched down and covered my face with both hands.

My voice came out muffled against my palms.

"What did I do to deserve this…"

A few seconds of silence.

I looked up and found Lucas watching me.

"Why does it have to be you?" I said. "Out of everyone."

He didn't answer.

It was the first time I'd ever seen him take a hit like that without deflecting. No sharpness. No counterquestion. No that'snotmyproblem distance. Just silence. Like he had no move to make.

I didn't know what answer I was even looking for.

I stood up, wiped my face with the back of my hand, and steadied my voice.

"The 'death trigger' thing you mentioned. What exactly does that mean?"

Lucas blinked — clearly not expecting the pivot.

"It's like..." He paused, arms crossing. "An instantkill mechanic. Like in an endless runner. Say the wrong thing, touch the wrong thing — triggers, resets, back to the start."

"And the time?" I pressed. "You said every death was hitting around one o'clock —"

He pulled out his phone.

The screen lit up.

1:01 PM.

We both went quiet.

Past one o'clock. Well past.

Time isn't the trigger.

So what actually is?

Neither of us had an answer. Lucas stood with his arms crossed, head down, staring at the pavement without moving.

I watched him stand like that, and something in the back of my mind shook loose.

There was a whole week in high school when I convinced myself he had a thing for a girl at the other end of the hallway. Because every time he passed that stretch, he'd slow down and stare in that direction, some unreadable look on his face. I'd been so eaten up by it I stopped walking that route entirely. Rerouted myself every single day to avoid seeing it.

Zoe was the one who told me, eventually. She'd laughed a little when she said it. He does that when he's thinking. He's not looking at anything. He never is.

I had spent three years memorizing his details. Coffee, no sugar. Writes with his left hand. Only ties his shoelaces in one loop. Taps his chest twice before a debate round starts, like a signal he's sending himself.

But the Lucas Vaughn standing in front of me right now.

None of it matched anything I'd kept in that mental file.

The person I'd spent three years carrying around wasn't really him.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter