Chapter 2

Lily

A wave of nausea hit me. I didn't say a word. I bolted.

I pushed through the private curtains and out the back exit, the biting Manhattan wind hitting my face like a slap. I didn't stop until I slammed the door of our Brooklyn loft behind me.

I began to dismantle my life.

I grabbed the ninety-nine paper roses Tristan had folded from old newspapers and shoveled them into a trash bag. I yanked the string of beer can tabs he'd collected for "promise rings" and tore his pencil sketches off the brick wall—drawings of me in wedding gowns that felt like insults now.

Every anniversary, he'd pull me close, his eyes wet with that practiced, tragic sincerity.

"Lily, I'm so broke. All I have to give you is my heart. But I'll work my ass off. One day, I'll buy you real diamonds and the biggest wedding this city has ever seen."

He wasn't broke. He was a billionaire playing a part, and I was just the mark.

I laughed, a dry, jagged sound that hurt my chest. Everything I'd once treated like a holy relic went straight into the bin.

The front door clicked open. Tristan walked in, stopped dead, and saw the bulging black bag.

He crossed the room in two strides, his fingers digging into my wrist. "Lily? Why are you trashing our things? What happened tonight?"

His eyes were narrow, hunting for a lie. "Where were you?"

I pasted a look of cool, detached exhaustion on my face. "I've been here packing. I have a bus to catch for Ohio in the morning. I'm done, Tristan."

He pulled out a greasy paper bag from the bodega.

"Are you still mad?" He tried to smile, but it looked strained. "Come on, look, babe. I drove for Lyft all night so I could get you this pastrami sandwich. You haven't eaten. I'll just take the scraps, okay?"

I didn't even look at the food. "Eat it yourself. I'm going to sleep."

He blocked the hallway, his body a solid wall. "What is this? Are you seriously leaving? Did those girls at the gallery get into your head? You're acting like you're suddenly too good for me."

He looked wounded, his brow furrowed. "I've been saving every cent for a baby. That's why I don't buy expensive shit. I wanted our kid to have a real life."

The word baby hit me like a kick to the gut.

In my last life, I'd nearly died delivering his three sons, only for him to hand them to Beatrice like luggage. My own blood, raised to never know my name.

I didn't argue. I just shoved him hard against the doorframe.

"We're finished, Tristan."

I ducked into the bedroom and slammed the lock.

He pounded on the door in panic. "Lily, don't do this! We've spent three years building this! I love you—I'd give you my life! Please, just talk to me!"

I sat on the floor, listening to him beg through the wood.

The heir to Crawford Private Equity, acting out a poverty-stricken romance in a leaking loft.

That was the love he'd sold me. I was done buying it.

…

Around 2 a.m., a dry, stinging thirst woke me.

I crept out into the hallway. The living room was dim, lit only by the orange glow of a cigarette by the window.

Tristan was leaning against the glass, his silhouette sharp and cold. He was on the phone, his voice devoid of the tremor he'd used with me.

"Lily is still packing," he said, his tone flat. "She's not budging."

Beatrice's voice drifted through the speaker—crisp, bored, and biting.

"It's a surrogate, Tristan. Stop acting like the sky is falling. If she wants to crawl back to the Midwest, let her. We aren't exactly running out of options."

Tristan exhaled a plume of smoke, watching it drift toward the ceiling.

"Lily's different," he said.

I froze in the doorway, a fraction of a second of hope trying to claw its way up.

"She's young, she's pretty," he added, his voice ice-cold. "And best of all, she's free."

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter