Chapter 3

“I did what you asked. I didn't go into the alley yesterday.”

I looked down at once.

There was no scar.

Not a trace of it.

Twelve years earlier, Olivia had cut through that alley, where a stray dog had gone after her. I'd been walking nearby and run to help.

The bite had badly damaged my left wrist. The injury had left a permanent mark and ended my piano playing.

I'd never wished I'd done anything differently.

Eighteen-year-old Olivia had cradled my hurt hand and said, “You saved me, Nathan. I promise I'll take care of you for the rest of my life.”

One week ago, she'd finally made it impossible to believe that promise anymore.

We'd gone to a friend's engagement party. Marcus sat down at the piano and played “Mariage d'Amour.”

Everyone applauded when he finished. A friend happened to mention that I'd once played piano myself.

Olivia laughed, looking at the scar on my wrist.

“Nathan, a pianist? Come on. That hand hasn't been good for anything in years.”

The banquet hall was brightly lit, but I stood there feeling frozen.

At eighteen, I'd never imagined the girl I'd put myself in danger for would someday laugh at the wound I'd taken protecting her.

The eighteen-year-old standing before me couldn't have imagined what she'd do to my love for her twelve years later, either.

I stared at the unmarked skin on my wrist and began to laugh, even with tears running down my face.

Changing the past was possible.

I smiled at Olivia. She still didn't understand any of this.

“Can you do one more thing for me?

“Stay away from Nathan Reed. For good.”

She went still. All the excitement drained out of her expression.

“What?”

“Don't tell me you love me. Leave me alone, and don't come back.”

She took an unsteady step backward, her eyes already wet.

“Why?

“Nathan Reed, don't you know how much I love you?”

“I do.”

I raised my face to hers, my eyes red and swollen.

“I know exactly how much.

“When I left my textbook at home, you handed me yours and got in trouble instead of me.

“When someone was spreading rumors about me, you rounded up your friends, tracked him down, and told him to leave me alone.

“If I so much as caught a cold or ran a fever, you noticed before anyone else. You'd take me straight to the school nurse.

“I know you loved me then.

“But the woman you'll turn into is cruel to me.

“You can't imagine how cruel.”

For a while, she only looked at me. Then she came closer, her voice rough with tears.

“I don't believe it, Nathan.

“I love you. How could I do anything to hurt you?”

She was so sure. I remembered her taking my hand out on that deserted school field, her cheeks flushed and her eyes bright as stars.

“Nathan Reed, I love you.

“More than anybody in the world.”

She was right about that. She did love me.

How could someone who loved me that much bring herself to hurt me?

What had happened by thirty that made her forget?

How had she stopped loving me at all?

We stood without speaking for a long time.

At last, I decided she needed to see her future for herself.

I opened the bedroom door. Not a sound came from the rest of the house.

The dirty breakfast plates were still on the table, and the room around them was a mess.

This was what married life had become.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter