Chapter 4

“You're always saying I never include you when I go out with my coworkers. So this time, I invited you.”

He was too busy watching the door to see how hurt I was.

“Evan, do you know what day it is?”

He looked at me with no sign of recognition.

I spoke evenly. “Evan, it's over between us.”

Someone's popper went off.

“To Paige and her first big deal!”

The cheers and popping drowned me out.

Evan hurried to Paige and wrapped an arm around her.

I watched them hold each other for a moment. Then I let my popper fall and left.

My mother had texted half an hour earlier. “Your dad and I just boarded. I'm so glad you changed your mind, Sofia.”

The man she wanted me to meet was already in Chicago. According to her, he'd agreed to join us for dinner on Wednesday.

I texted back, “Okay,” and headed straight to the airport's private terminal to meet them.

The next day, I showed my parents around the North Side.

We were leaving a store when Evan called.

He sounded desperate to find out where I was.

I had no interest in talking to him, but he sounded like something was genuinely wrong. After a moment, I sent him my location.

He arrived soon afterward, hurrying toward me with Paige trailing behind.

The sight of my parents made him stop. He pulled me away from them and kept his voice down. “Why are they here? I told you I'm spending Wednesday with Paige. I can't have dinner with your parents.”

I looked at him coolly. “If you're not coming, why can't I invite someone else?”

He decided I was just sulking and let it go.

He opened Instagram on his phone and pointed to a comment beneath a post. “Sofia, is this yours?”

I glanced at the screen.

There were several pictures from yesterday's party.

In one, his arm was around Paige.

In another, he was wiping cake onto her face.

In the third, their heads were close together.

It was Paige's account. Under the pictures, she'd written, “Celebrating my first big deal with my coworkers. Couldn't have asked for a better day.”

A whole room of people had been there. Yet every photo she'd posted was of her and Evan.

She wasn't being subtle.

I smiled and read the comment he was pointing at. “For the record, this guy's been with his girlfriend for five years.”

The commenter had attached a photo of Evan and me together.

I could see why he assumed I'd written it.

Evan stared at me. “People are attacking Paige. She's getting nasty messages nonstop. If this keeps spreading, it'll damage her reputation.

“Reply to that comment now. Say you're the girlfriend, you were at the party, and Paige and I are just friends.”

“What if I don't?”

He hesitated, then lowered his voice. “Sofia, this isn't like you.”

He looked at me as if I'd let him down.

Before I could respond, Paige burst into tears. “We're coworkers. That's all... If people at work see this, they'll think I stole him from you!”

A short distance away, my parents watched us with worried faces.

Evan tightened his jaw.

“If you won't help, Sofia, I'll talk to your parents.”

He started toward them.

They'd worried about me enough. I caught him before he reached them. “I'll reply.”

I opened the post and typed my response.

“I'm the girlfriend they're talking about. This man and I are no longer together. What either of them does now is their business, not mine.”

Evan frowned at the screen.

“You didn't have to say it that way just to explain. You know I don't want to marry anyone but you.”

Still, the problem was handled, and the tension left his face.

He looked at me gratefully.

“I'll hurry back on Wednesday, Sofia. I'll make time to see your parents.”

I said nothing.

He took that as a yes, draped his arm around Paige, and walked away.

We sat down to dinner at six on Wednesday.

At seven, Evan texted that he'd taken Paige home and was heading over.

At eight, he said she had cramps and he'd gone to buy her something for the pain, so he'd be a little late.

At nine, quick footsteps sounded in the hallway outside our dining room.

Evan came through the door.

“Sorry I'm so late.”

Then he saw the people at our table, and his smile disappeared.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter