Chapter 4

The days before the hearing were unbearable. People edited my photographs to make me look like a thief, tagged my account, and posted them with insults. Thousands of users shared them.

Someone even hung a large poster outside my dorm. Across it, in red, they'd written, “Thief! Get off our campus!”

The mouse jerked. “Your other life was worse. This time, you can still fight.”

I took a breath.

Then it told me to check the hospitals.

I crouched in the stairwell below the roof access and called the general hospital's public patient information line. I asked whether Nolan's mother could be reached there, giving her name. The person answering couldn't find a listing for her and couldn't provide private medical records.

I tried another hospital, then another, working through every major one in the city.

Not one could confirm that she was there.

Nolan's story wasn't checking out. The ICU claim looked like another lie.

I squeezed the phone in my hand.

The mouse vibrated. “Stay calm. Tomorrow, have your statement about the recording notarized and preserve the original files. Then ask campus IT to help you export and verify your cloud upload activity. You need the times recorded by the service, not just the dates on your laptop.

“When the hearing starts on Friday, let him finish lying before you show any of it.”

I followed its instructions. With my authorization, the IT staff helped me preserve the account activity and verify the recorded upload times and file hashes. We signed statements documenting the process and had the signatures notarized.

The night before the hearing, I spread everything across my desk: the group call recording, the failed login history, the upload records, and my notes from the hospital calls.

Together, they answered the story he was telling about me.

The conference room was crowded the next afternoon. The associate dean was there, along with representatives from the university's academic committee and legal office.

Nolan sat across from me, looking worn out. The papers shook in his hands. His eyes were swollen and red.

Paige sat beside him, lips pressed together, her expression solemn.

Associate Dean Andrew Collins opened the hearing. “Nolan, go ahead.”

Nolan took a breath and gave his most polished performance yet. He went through his timeline, his file screenshots, Paige's account of what she'd seen, my supposed threats, and my refusal to help his mother.

He fitted every detail into place. The story became sadder and more convincing as he spoke.

At the end, he looked at me. Tears fell onto the table. “I only want my own work back so my mom can get treatment. Ethan, we were best friends. I still don't understand why you'd do this…”

He bowed his head and sobbed, his shoulders trembling.

Daniel looked affected. Andrew frowned with sympathy. Around the table, people stared at me as if a confession was the only reasonable thing I could offer.

Nolan slowly lifted his head. He couldn't quite conceal his satisfaction. Paige kept looking down, her fingers locked together as though she could hardly bear to be there.

They thought I had no answer.

Mr. Collins turned to me. “Nolan has finished. Is there anything you'd like to add, Ethan? You haven't presented your evidence at this hearing yet. If you have nothing further, we'll have to reach a preliminary finding from the material before us.”

No one made a sound. I could feel each slow beat of my heart.

The mouse buzzed in my pocket. “Now.”

I stood, resting my hands on the table. “I have evidence.”

My voice didn't shake. I took a flash drive from my bag and carried it to the computer connected to the projector.

The first file was the video I'd recorded that night.

I opened it and pressed play.

Nolan's satisfied expression vanished. His face went white.

Paige jumped up so abruptly that her chair toppled backward with a crash.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter