Her Tears Were All They Believed

Laughter carried through the Whitmore house for hours, loud enough that I would have heard it from the basement if I were still alive.

My brothers made a point of letting it carry.

They wanted me to know that nobody missed me.

“Nathan, you've had such a long day. Caleb, Owen, have some too.”

Brianna had made cookies. She passed them around with a sweet smile, then stood behind Nathan and rubbed his shoulders.

These were men whose decisions could frighten an entire city. Around her, they let every hard edge disappear.

I drifted back through the freezer's steel door.

My body was still curled in the corner, cramped into a position no living person could hold for long.

My skin was blue and purple. Ice coated my eyelashes and caught in my hair.

My fingers were worse.

I had scratched at the door until my nails bent backward or broke off. Frozen blood crusted around my fingertips.

I hardly recognized what was left of me.

While I stared, numb, at my ruined hands, the old butler brought drinks into the living room and dropped to his knees again.

It was his third attempt to get them to let me out.

“Mr. Whitmore, please. It's been three days. Miss Audrey was never healthy after the way she grew up. If you leave her there any longer, she'll die.”

Nathan stopped with his cup in his hand. He frowned. Caleb slowly lowered his newspaper.

For an instant, they both looked troubled.

Before either could answer, tears spilled from Brianna's eyes. “This is all because of me,” she whispered. “If I hadn't upset Audrey, she wouldn't be going through this.”

She stood unsteadily.

“I'll apologize. I'll get on my knees if that's what she wants. Let her out and put me in there.”

Whatever concern my brothers had shown disappeared.

Nathan caught her arm and drew her back.

He rounded on the butler. “Keep your mouth shut. Do you work for this family, or are you her lapdog?”

Owen laughed without warmth. “Get this straight, Walter. Growing up in that dump ruined her. She's not fit to be a Whitmore. Brianna is our only sister.”

Our only sister.

Even without a body, I felt myself shake.

When they brought me home, they had called me the daughter our parents never got to raise. They promised they wouldn't put Brianna ahead of me.

In the days before they locked me up, I had stayed awake for three nights carving Nathan a little walnut keychain. The work left my palms raw and blistered.

Brianna grabbed it out of my hands. When I reached to take it back, she flung herself into the icy lake and screamed that I had pushed her.

My brothers accepted her accusation without a question and hauled me to the freezer.

So this was what they really believed. Brianna was the only sister who counted.

I laughed bitterly to myself.

I didn't want to belong to this family anymore.

The front doors suddenly flew open.

An employee who had been watching the freezer stumbled inside, trembling and pale. “Mr. Whitmore! Something's happened!”

His voice broke. “We haven't heard a thing from the freezer. I looked through the vent, and—”

He swallowed. “Miss Audrey… I couldn't see her breathing. She's covered in ice.”

The living room went quiet.

Nathan jumped up. Fear crossed his face so briefly that I almost doubted I'd seen it.

Caleb and Owen glanced at each other and started toward the exit.

Finally, they were going to look.

Brianna gave a small cry and crumpled to the floor, holding Nathan's sleeve. “Nathan… is Audrey still mad at me?”

She brought a shaking hand to her chest. This time, the fear in her eyes was real.

She knew she had changed the setting from 14°F to -58°F. If I was dead, they might discover what she had done. Her tears came faster.

“My birth parents said she used to pretend to faint back home whenever she didn't want to work.”

Her voice shook.

“Could she be doing that now? Trying to frighten you into making me leave?”

She looked down.

“Maybe I should go. You're her biological brothers. I'm just the daughter of the people who took her away.”

She knew exactly what to say.

My brothers' fear for me gave way to guilt over her distress, then anger at me for causing it.

Nathan let out a scornful laugh. “She's pretending she's dead now?”

Caleb adjusted his gold-rimmed glasses. “People fake unconsciousness. They hold their breath. It's hardly a clever trick.”

Owen scowled. “She couldn't stand to see Brianna happy, so she's pulling this today?”

He strode toward the door. “All right. If she wants to play dead, we'll go see the show.”

Brianna went white.

She had meant to stop them from checking on me.

Instead, they were actually going.

She clutched her chest and coughed hard, swaying where she knelt. “Nathan… it hurts. Please stay. Don't leave me, okay?”

But she had forgotten what their devotion did to them.

Anyone who hurt Brianna became their enemy. They loved her enough to be vicious to me.

At her coughing, Nathan smashed his cup onto the floor. Pieces flew across the room.

“Don't worry, Brianna. Go lie down.” He shook with anger. “She thinks she can upset you like this? I'll bring her back here and make her beg you to forgive her.”

Caleb opened his medical bag and took out a syringe, handling it with deliberate calm.

“She wants to pretend she's dead?” he said. “By the time I'm finished, she'll wish she were.”

Owen loosened his tie and went ahead of them. “We'll knock the door down. Let's see how long she keeps pretending when we pull her out.”

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter