Chapter 1
At my wedding dinner, another woman wore the Whitmore family brooch.
Our wedding photographer took close-ups while the guests said she looked like the bride.
When she offered to return it, my fiancé told her to keep it.
“She won it. It’s her prize.”
I hadn’t said a word.
Somehow, I was still the one ruining the evening.
Then Paige’s neck began to itch—and Andrew left my wedding dinner to take her to the hospital.
By the time I got back to the private lounge, Paige had a crowd around her, all reaching for their phones.
The vintage Whitmore brooch sparkled on her silver dress. The photographer we'd hired for our wedding was taking close-ups of it as the women nearby praised the stones.
One of Andrew's cousins raised his glass of whiskey.
“Some prize, Andrew. Without those invitations, I'd have guessed Paige was your bride.”
Paige's eyes filled at once.
“Don't say that. Natalie will think I'm taking something away from her.”
Everyone turned to look at me.
Andrew sat in the middle of the room. He noticed me in the doorway and gave a slight frown.
“Why are you staying by the door? You're making it look as if someone here hurt you.”
I nearly laughed.
They'd embarrassed me, and now apparently I was causing trouble by saying nothing.
Andrew extended a hand.
Usually, I would have gone to him and taken the seat beside him. I would have kept smiling until both families were satisfied there was no problem.
I stayed where I was.
His face tightened.
Julian got up and approached me. He had a mild face and the easy smile he wore even while resolving the disputes my father refused to let become lawsuits.
Until my twenty-first birthday, I'd thought he was the one person who would never make me feel small.
He bent toward me, keeping his voice low.
“Natalie, don't embarrass Andrew with both families watching.”
“Have I even said a word?”
Julian hesitated.
Paige reached for the clasp of the brooch. Tears ran down her face as she glanced from Andrew to me.
“I'll give it to Natalie. It's her wedding dinner. I shouldn't wear something that makes her unhappy.”
Before she could undo it, Andrew spoke.
“Keep it on.”
Then he looked at me.
“She picked the winning key. It's her prize.”
I let out a soft laugh.
No one spoke.
Andrew watched me coldly.
“It was just a game,” Julian said, frowning. “Why make everyone uncomfortable?”
He moved a little closer to Paige, positioning himself between us.
“She's felt unwanted her whole life. Tonight she finally got to enjoy herself. Can't you let her have that?”
I'd heard it all before.
Things hadn't started this way.
Before Paige and her mother became part of my family, Andrew kept his promises, and Julian had always been the friend I could count on to back me up.
Then my father married Paige's mother. After that, fairness stopped being the question whenever we disagreed. The question was how to keep Paige from crying.
She needs it more than you.
You can handle it.
Just let her have it.
I looked at her.
She stood beside Andrew, tears caught on her lashes. But she wasn't afraid when she met my eyes.
One corner of her mouth shifted, just a little.
Andrew rose and walked over to me.
He reached to stroke my hair, the gesture he'd always used to quiet an argument.
I turned away before he could touch me.
Someone behind him gasped.
For a moment, he kept his hand raised. Then he dropped it.
His expression hardened.
“I'll meet you at the bridal studio tomorrow. Ten o'clock.”
I looked at him. “You remembered that?”
He seemed to think the question was absurd.
“When have I ever broken a promise to you?”
I had plenty of answers.
Before I gave him one, Paige coughed on the other side of the room.
He turned immediately.
“What's wrong?”
She shook her head and brushed the skin below the brooch.
“Nothing, really. My neck's itchy. Maybe I'm just not used to wearing this.”
Andrew went to her and inspected a faint patch of red near her collarbone. He grabbed his coat and settled it over her shoulders.
“We're going to the hospital.”
“You don't need to do that.” Paige glanced at me. “Natalie's upset already. I don't want to spoil the rest of her night.”
“You haven't spoiled anything.”
Julian studied me and sighed.
“Let it go, Natalie. Andrew's marrying you. Paige is like a little sister to us.”
I faced him.
“Then why is she taking the vacation her sister's fiancé picked out?”
His polite smile vanished.
“Why do you have to put it that way?”
Andrew turned back to me.
“Enough, Natalie.” His voice was cold.
I found I didn't want to say anything else.
They had arranged for Paige to get the trip I'd planned, leaving me an empty case. Even then, they wanted me to smile and blame my luck.
At the end of the night, Paige still had a little redness under the brooch.
Andrew drove her to the hospital.
Julian remained to take me home.
“Try not to dwell on tonight.”
“You know what Andrew's like. He isn't warm when he talks, but he does care.”
“He'll be at your fitting tomorrow. Three days from now, you'll be his wife.”
He put both hands on my shoulders.
“You won, Natalie. There's no reason to fight Paige over every little thing.”
I held his gaze.
“What exactly did I win?”
He went still.
He started to speak, then couldn't.
Even Julian couldn't tell me what was mine and mine alone.
I gave a short, unhappy laugh.
“Nothing, then.”
Before I went to bed, I bought a one-way plane ticket for the morning of the wedding.
