The Cost of a Wish
During the next two days, the Wheel of Wishes kept gaining new users.
Someone's crush admitted they liked them back. Someone near the bottom of our grade's academic rankings moved into the top hundred. One student's parents reconciled. Another student took home a championship.
Not one wish failed.
The class went into a frenzy.
To them, this proved Audrey had forgiven them. It also proved I was the only guilty person left.
My desk ended up beside the trash can. They coated my chair with glue, sliced through my cafeteria card, and covered my homework in black ink.
Each day brought another message on the desk: “Why don't you join her?”
I didn't let them do it without a fight.
I ripped their pictures of me off the walls. When they emptied water onto my desk, I threw it back over them. I downloaded every video they had secretly taken of me and shared in our class chat.
There were forty-six of them, though. I could stand up to one. I couldn't take on forty-six at once.
…
Eventually, they pulled me into the very restroom stall where Audrey had been trapped. One person held my hands while another took my phone.
Vanessa put the Wheel of Wishes in front of my face. “You're the only one who hasn't used it. Go on. Spin it and show us you had nothing to do with Audrey dying.”
I braced myself against the door and stared at her. “How would that show anything?”
“Audrey only helps good people.” Vanessa smiled, as though that settled it. “You won't spin because you know she won't forgive you. Right?”
Megan stood at her side. “Stop lying, Rachel. If you didn't do anything, why were you so determined to stop me? Were you hoping my mom would die before anybody could expose you?”
As I looked at her, the last affection I had for her drained away. “You know what I did to help Audrey.”
“I know you were the last one to see her.” Megan turned her face aside. “Everybody else made some jokes. Then she saw you, and the next day she jumped. Are you saying that had nothing to do with you?”
They pressed closer.
Hands clamped down on my shoulders.
Someone seized my wrist and tried to push my hand onto the screen.
“Do it for Audrey!”
“Make her use it!”
“If Audrey refuses her wish, we'll know she killed her!”
I fought to get loose. My hand struck the wall.
Vanessa caught my index finger and dragged it toward the wheel. “Quit fighting. We all did it, and nothing happened to us. What's there to worry about?”
That was the question I had never managed to answer.
Why had the wheel done nothing but help them? Why had Audrey invited the whole class, not just a few people?
If it existed only to grant wishes, why did it need everyone? What was it waiting to get from them?
For a moment, all I could see was Audrey curled up in this stall. They had surrounded her like this, too.
Everybody laughed. Everybody insisted it was a joke.
Whenever she tried to speak, ten voices talked over her.
She'd cried when she told me about it. “Rachel, they've already made up their minds that I'm bad. The more I try to explain, the more fun they have.”
Now the same people had me pinned here, doing it all again in her name.
They called it justice for Audrey.
They had never believed she was innocent. They wanted an excuse to keep believing they were right.
I shut my eyes. Audrey, was this what it felt like? You hadn't done anything, but they wouldn't even leave you enough space to stand up and speak.
“Get on with it!”
Vanessa crushed my hand in hers. My fingertip hovered just above the display.
Before it could touch, every phone went off together.
Words emerged across the wheel: “All 46 wishes have been claimed. Now, please choose how you will repay them.”
