Chapter 1

The third year of Rhys's affair, I sent his mistress's intimate photos out to every platform I could find. Then I poured gasoline over myself and told the whole world I'd burn it all down and drag everyone with me.

Lydia fled Boston that same night, terrified.

I thought I'd won.

But my brother sold his condo to cover the lawsuit and the settlement, and when that wasn't enough, he borrowed from loan sharks. In the end the weight of it crushed him, and he jumped from the roof of a high-rise.

He left me a recording. His voice was hoarse and hollow, every sentence breaking in the middle.

"Margo, please, just stop. We've lost everything. Mom and Dad aged ten years overnight, and I can't hold on anymore."

Mom collapsed over his things, sobbing until she passed out. Dad wrapped his thin, shaking hands around my throat and screamed in my face.

"How many more lives are you going to ruin before you're satisfied?"

The tears ran down my face without a sound, and that was the moment I finally woke up.

I stopped tracking every woman who came near Rhys. I stopped asking, over and over, about the lipstick on his collar. When I caught him sitting alone with an old photo of the two of them, I went and brought Lydia back myself.

Then, on her birthday, she closed her eyes over her candles and made a wish: she wanted to be the real Mrs. Calder, just once.

I had the divorce papers printed before the smoke from the candles cleared. I signed them and set them down in front of her.

Rhys tore them in half. He grabbed my jaw, and his voice cracked as he said, "Margot, where did it go, that stubborn I'll die before I divorce you act of yours?"


I looked at his bloodshot eyes and answered calmly. "Is it the terms? I'll walk away with nothing. Give her what she wants."

He shoved me away. "You blasted those photos everywhere and never once thought about giving anybody what they wanted. You were ready to take us all down with you. Why play the saint now?"

My chest tightened again.

"You're right," I said. "I lost my mind back then. I'm clear-headed now, and I'm setting you free. Isn't that what you wanted?"

He had nothing to say to that. His chest rose and fell hard, like a caged animal with nothing to lash out at.

Lydia's eyes filled up. "I'm so sorry, Rhys. I never should have made that wish. Please don't fight because of me."

Then she lifted her hand and slapped herself across the face, twice. Rhys caught her wrist at once and spoke to her in the gentlest voice I'd heard from him in years.

"It's not your fault. I just lost my temper. Come on, I've got a surprise waiting for you at the beach. Let's go celebrate there."

He led her toward the door, and as they passed me he slowed for half a step.

"Margo, I don't want to fight with you. Wait for me. When I get back, we'll sit down and talk this through."

The front door closed behind them.

I got up, picked up the cake, and dropped it in the trash. Then I took the paycheck I'd just cashed out at the ATM, put the bills in an envelope, and drove to my parents' house.

The door of the old apartment was shut, just like I knew it would be.

I took a breath and knocked, and the silence on the other side was complete. I swallowed the lump in my throat and made my voice as soft as I could.

"Mom, Dad, it's been three years since you've said a word to me. Please, could you just talk to me?"

Nothing.

My tears hit the floor and spread into dark little stains. Three years ago, at my brother's funeral, my parents had disowned me in front of everyone, and no matter how many times I'd begged since then, that door had never opened.

I slid the envelope through the gap under the door and walked away.

I followed the road with no destination in mind, and somehow I ended up at the beach where Owen and I used to play when we were kids. I was just going to snap a picture and head home. Then I saw them through the window of a seafood restaurant on the boardwalk, a few familiar faces gathered around one table.

Rhys sat next to Lydia, who wore a paper party hat and was smiling as she blew out her candles. My parents sat across from her, glowing with warmth.

I stepped closer without thinking. Through the glass I watched Mom set down a bowl of clam chowder in front of her.

"Happy birthday, sweetheart. Made it just the way you like it."

Lydia leaned her head against Mom's shoulder. "Thank you, Mama Di."

Dad slid a check across the table. "I'm too old to know what you young people like these days. There's ten thousand dollars in there. Buy yourself something you love."

Her eyes lit up. "Papa Rick, you're the best. In my next life I'm going to be your real daughter."

Rhys laughed and tapped her on the nose. "And there's one more surprise."

He clapped twice. A violinist began to play, and someone pushed a cake toward the table on a cart. As the figure came closer, the blurry outline sharpened into a face I knew better than my own.

I stopped breathing. The blood in my veins turned to ice.

My brother's voice carried clearly through the glass, every word hitting me like a blow. "Happy birthday, Lyds."

Next Chapter