Chapter Two

Thea's POV

“Follow her example.”

Everyone Margot took from me ended up saying some version of that.

I was nine when I broke my leg tumbling down the steps outside the orphanage’s back door.

I lay on the concrete, sweating from the pain. The teacher looked down at me, her tone indifferent.

“I pay a little more attention to Margot for a few days, and you throw yourself down the stairs to get my attention? So young, and already this manipulative. Why can’t you be more like her?”

After my fiancé met Margot, he often compared me to her, too.

“You grew up in the same orphanage. How come none of her smarts rubbed off on you?”

I stood in the parking lot and watched my parents and brother drive away with Margot. A moment ago, they’d been insisting on taking me to the hospital.

When I was nine, it had been my teacher telling me to be more like Margot. Tonight, it was my mom.

Three days later, my family put together an art exhibition to make it up to me.

Mom held both my hands, her expression so tender it was as if she were afraid I might break.

“We know how hard things were for you growing up. But you kept painting through all of it. Do you realize what an achievement that is?”

“After today, people will know who you are.”

“You and your paintings mean more to us than anything.”

“I’ve picked a title: In Her Own Hand. Let everyone see what our Thea has created with her own hands.”

Hearing Mom talk about my paintings made my eyes sting again. They were my family, after all. Maybe this time I really could trust them.

Then I turned and saw Margot standing beside Matteo, and I wasn’t so sure.

Matteo cleared his throat.

“We couldn’t have gotten everything set up today without Margot.”

I hurried into the gallery and stopped just inside.

Mom followed me in. When she saw the labels, she drew in a quiet breath.

It was the same under every painting. My work, all credited to Margot Ellery.

Dad’s expression hardened.

“Who did this?”

Before Margot could answer, a gallery employee hurried over.

“We’re very sorry. Ms. Ellery is well known in the art world. When the show was booked, we assumed it was hers.”

“To be honest, we’ve never heard of Thea Castellane.”

That hurt worse than a slap.

Margot stepped in front of me. Tears ran down her cheeks, but there was a smile in her eyes.

“Thea, I’m so sorry.”

“I’m an orphan. I don’t have any money, and I’ve never had a show of my own. I didn’t know it would turn out like this.”

I was shaking so hard my teeth chattered.

I wanted to shout it for everyone in the gallery to hear.

It was her.

She’d done it on purpose.

She’d been doing this her whole life. She always found a way to steal the moments that mattered most to me and make them her own.

I looked at my parents and brother. They looked angry.

I waited for just one of them to say this was wrong.

Instead, Matteo turned to Margot with a gentle smile.

“Don’t feel bad. Having your name on them might actually get Thea’s paintings some attention.”

“You think she’ll help me get noticed?” My voice broke halfway through. “Matteo, how is anyone here supposed to know I painted these?”

Dad turned to me, his eyes cold.

“Margot’s paintings are a lot better than yours. You want your name put back on them now? Are you trying to embarrass us in front of the press?”

Mom came over to settle the argument. She ended up standing right in front of Margot.

“Margot doesn’t have anyone who loves her the way we love you. She has nothing. Can’t you think about her feelings just this once?”

“It’s one exhibition. There’s no need to make such a fuss.”

Then she turned to the staff and told them to take down my paintings and replace them with Margot’s.

She said my work wasn’t polished enough. It would hurt Margot’s reputation.

The reporters showed up on schedule.

So, with some reluctance, my family put the pearl necklace they’d had made for me around Margot’s neck.

Margot smiled for the cameras between my parents, wearing my pearls.

The title Mom had chosen for my exhibition still hung overhead in the hall.

In Her Own Hand.

My paintings had all ended up in the trash cans below.

For a long moment, I stood there, stunned. Then I took out my phone. When I booked a flight for early the next morning, I chose a one-way ticket.

Previous Chapter
Next Chapter