
Everyone Who Loved Me Ended Up Loving Her
Piper Hayes · Completed · 6.4k Words
Introduction
Her name was Margot Ellery. We’d shared a bunk bed at the orphanage.
For as long as I could remember, I’d been able to see a number above people’s heads. The higher it climbed, the more they favored her.
At the orphanage, there was one teacher who’d always been especially kind to me. The month her number reached 64, the extra almond cookie at the bottom of my bowl disappeared. She stopped reaching for my hand, too.
The day before our wedding, my fiancé’s number stood at 91. He hemmed and hawed, then said maybe we should put off the wedding a little longer. There was lipstick on his shirt collar.
“Okay,” I said. That night, I took my suitcase and left the city.
Not long after that, my birth family found me: Don Vincent of the Castellane family, his wife, Helena, and my brother, Matteo, who seemed ready to do anything for me.
Still, I couldn’t help testing them. Every time I praised Margot, the numbers above their heads dropped, until all three reached negative fifty thousand.
That was when I finally trusted them. They felt like family to me.
Then came my birthday party. The three chairs at the head table stayed empty.
They finally walked in as the party was winding down. Above each of their heads was the same number.
Chapter 1
Thea's POV
Everyone who ever cared about me ended up choosing the same girl.
Her name was Margot Ellery. We’d shared a bunk bed at the orphanage.
For as long as I could remember, I’d been able to see a number above people’s heads. The higher it climbed, the more they favored her.
At the orphanage, there was one teacher who’d always been especially kind to me. The month her number reached 64, the extra almond cookie at the bottom of my bowl disappeared. She stopped reaching for my hand, too.
The day before our wedding, my fiancé’s number stood at 91. He hemmed and hawed, then said maybe we should put off the wedding a little longer. There was lipstick on his shirt collar.
“Okay,” I said. That night, I took my suitcase and left the city.
Not long after that, my birth family found me: Don Vincent of the Castellane family, his wife, Helena, and my brother, Matteo, who seemed ready to do anything for me.
Still, I couldn’t help testing them. Every time I praised Margot, the numbers above their heads dropped, until all three reached negative fifty thousand.
That was when I finally trusted them. They felt like family to me.
Then came my birthday party. The three chairs at the head table stayed empty.
They finally walked in as the party was winding down. Above each of their heads was the same number.
“Thea, honey, we’re so late.”
Mom hurried across the half-empty banquet hall. Guests were already collecting their coats.
Dad followed, avoiding my eyes. Matteo said a shipment had been held up at the docks. They’d come straight from the negotiations.
My parents glanced at each other. I’d seen that look before. Each was waiting for the other to speak.
I checked the numbers above their heads.
I said nothing. I’d been through this too many times. I was already figuring out how to leave without making a scene.
Mom must have noticed how hard I was working to keep smiling, because her own smile faltered. Her fingers trembled a little as she tucked my hair behind my ear.
“We let you down. We won’t leave you waiting like this again.”
Dad nodded to a server, who wheeled a cart through a side door. On it sat a three-tier tower of lemon tarts. Dad fastened a small silver clip in my hair, studied it for a moment, then nodded.
“No tears tonight, birthday girl.”
They looked at me as though I were something precious they’d spent half their lives searching for.
I might have believed they’d simply gotten stuck in traffic, if I hadn’t seen those numbers go from negative fifty thousand to 12.
Matteo raised his instant camera.
The server lifted the cover.
The tower had collapsed. The icing flowers on top tilted to one side. The tart shells had caved in on one another, and lemon filling had seeped through the gaps and pooled on the cart.
No one spoke.
Someone had to clean it up. I got to my feet and picked up the platter. I’d been looking forward to this for months. I carried it over to the trash can in the corner.
“It’s fine,” I said. “I don’t eat sweets anymore anyway.”
Matteo came after me and lowered his voice.
“We’ll be up all night closing this deal. Once it’s done, we’re going to the cabin by the lake. A whole week, just like I promised.”
He had dark circles under his eyes, and his shirt collar was rumpled. None of them had gotten a full night’s sleep in weeks.
My throat tightened. I stared down at the edge of the platter.
Then the last voice I wanted to hear came from the doorway.
“Sorry to interrupt, Don. I just need your signature on the last page.”
Margot stood there in a navy suit, a Castellane Holdings pin on her lapel and a stack of papers in her hand.
My chest felt as if someone had reached inside and squeezed.
Matteo’s face lit up. “Margot? What are you doing here?”
My parents both broke into smiles before they had time to hide them.
Mom glanced at me and spoke gently.
“We almost got cheated on that deal today. Margot spotted a problem in the contract and saved us thirty million dollars.”
“The Brandt family set us up,” Dad added.
Margot came over and linked arms with Mom, a shy smile on her face.
“I just gave it another look. It was no big deal.”
Dad looked pleased.
“Well, that extra look was worth thirty million. No more working on the sidelines. From now on, you’ll work directly with me.”
They started talking business. I stood off to the side, empty-handed.
Just like at the orphanage. Wherever Margot went, I ended up in the background.
When I snapped out of it, she was standing between Dad and Matteo, with Mom’s hand on her shoulder.
The numbers above their heads had gone up again.
I clenched my fists and coughed twice, hard.
Matteo finally turned around. “Are you feeling okay?”
Mom immediately pressed a hand to my forehead. Dad pulled out his car keys and insisted on taking me to the hospital. Nothing I said would change his mind.
When we reached the car, Margot’s phone rang.
She checked the screen and said a few quiet words. By the time she hung up, her eyes were red.
Matteo let go of the car door.
“Was that the Brandts? Are they still giving you trouble?”
Margot shook her head, putting on a brave face. Her expression told a different story.
“It’s nothing. Just a little disagreement. I can handle it.”
“A little disagreement?” Mom said. “They think they can push you around because you’re a young woman.”
Dad was already typing a message, his jaw tight.
“I’ll meet with them myself tomorrow. They don’t get to touch my people.”
Mom turned to take Margot’s arm. I caught her sleeve.
“What about me?”
Mom had never looked at me with such impatience before.
She sighed, speaking to me as though I were a child refusing to get in the car.
“I know you and Margot have had your misunderstandings. But she saved us today.”
“Can’t you be a little more mature and follow her example?”
Last Chapters
#9 Chapter Nine
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#8 Chapter Eight
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#7 Chapter Seven
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#6 Chapter Six
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#5 Chapter Five
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#4 Chapter Four
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#3 Chapter Three
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#2 Chapter Two
Last Updated: 11/18/2026#1 Chapter One
Last Updated: 11/18/2026
You Might Like 😍
OUR NEW BEGINNING
Until the day she left.
Determined to start afresh, far from everything that hurt her, Olivia decides to leave the past behind. But some ties cannot be severed so easily.
Months later, an unexpected reunion brings the two face to face once more — and Brian realises, too late, that he has lost far more than he ever imagined.
Now, amidst hurt, secrets, and feelings that never truly faded, they must discover whether the love they destroyed in the past is still strong enough to deserve a second chance.
Because some stories end.
Others simply wait for the right moment to begin again.
Let Them Kneel
Cast out by her pack. Forgotten by the Lycans.
She lived among humans—quiet, invisible, tucked away in a town no one looked at twice.
But when her first heat comes without warning, everything changes.
Her body ignites. Her instincts scream. And something primal stirs beneath her skin—
summoning a big, bad Alpha who knows exactly how to quench her fire.
When he claims her, it’s ecstasy and ruin.
For the first time, she believes she’s been accepted.
Seen.
Chosen.
Until he leaves her the next morning—
like a secret never to be spoken.
But Kaelani is not what they thought.
Not wolfless. Not weak.
There is something ancient inside her. Something powerful. And it’s waking.
And when it does—
they’ll all remember the girl they tried to erase.
Especially him.
She’ll be the dream he keeps chasing… the one thing that ever made him feel alive.
Because secrets never stay buried.
And neither do dreams.
Tempted By The Enemy
She escapes to Preston Island to attend the wedding without informing him only to collide with Lucas’s hot, fiery and arrogant brother, the twenty-three-year-old, Nicholas Donnelly. Sparks immediately fly between them but Alyssa refuses to acknowledge them fearing her brother's wrath.
The wedding is over and Alyssa tries hard to forget the mysterious Nicholas Donnelly but can he forget her? Can he ignore the attraction he feels for her, feelings that have resurfaced after ten years?
What will Allyssa do when she is stalked by the man who has been invading her dreams since the day she met him? What will she do when she is whisked away to a deserted island by the unpredictable Nicholas Donnelly? Can she tame her heart or surrender to sinful temptations? Read to find out!
Part of the Temptation Series. Can be read as a standalone.
Off Limits On Purpose
So she built rules. Four of them. Written in the front of a notebook she carries everywhere.
Alex Carter was never supposed to get past the first one.
But he did. Slowly, without asking permission, in libraries and coffee carts and late nights that ran longer than either of them planned. He got past all of them. And somewhere in the middle of a semester Star didn't expect, she stopped guarding herself so carefully around him.
What she doesn't know is that he has a secret. A bet made in September, a deadline in December, and teammates who were watching from the beginning.
What he didn't expect is that it would stop mattering — and that by the time he understood why, it might already be too late.
She gave him everything she never gives anyone.
He just hasn't told her what it cost.
The CEO Above My Desk
“I know she does.”
“And what if she doesn’t want this kind of protection?”
“She will,” I say, my voice lowering slightly. “Because she needs a man who can give her the world.”
“And if the world burns?”
My hand tightens subtly at Violet’s waist.
“Then I’ll build her a new one,” I reply. “Even if I have to burn the old one down myself.”
I don’t work for Rowan Ashcroft.
I work beneath him.
From my desk, I decide who gets access to the most ruthless CEO in the city, and who never makes it past the lobby. I manage his time, his silence, his enemies. I keep his world running while my own quietly collapses under unpaid bills, a mother locked in rehab, and a brother who vanished without a goodbye.
Rowan Ashcroft is power wrapped in a tailored suit.
Cold. Untouchable. Merciless.
He doesn’t flirt. He doesn’t smile. He doesn’t see people, only usefulness.
And for a long time, I was just useful.
Until he started watching.
A shift in his attention is subtle at first. A pause too long. A look that lingers. Orders that pull me closer instead of pushing me away. The man who stands above my desk begins to control more than my schedule, and I realize too late that being noticed by Rowan Ashcroft is far more dangerous than being ignored.
Because men like him don’t crave affection.
They crave possession.
This was supposed to be a job.
Not a test of my limits.
Not a slow, deliberate descent into his authority.
But if Rowan Ashcroft decides I belong under his desk, then so be it.
Survival has a price, and the bills don’t care how I pay them.
The CEO's Midnight Remedy
My name is Aria Harper, and I just caught my fiancé Ethan screwing my stepsister Scarlett in our bed. While my world crumbled, they were planning to steal everything—my inheritance, my mother's legacy, even the company that should be mine.
But I'm not the naive girl they think I am.
Enter Devon Kane—eleven years older, dangerously powerful, and exactly the weapon I need. One month. One secret deal. Use his influence to save my company while I uncover the truth about my mother Elizabeth's "death" and the fortune they stole from me.
The plan was simple: fake my engagement, seduce information from my enemies, and walk away clean.
What I didn't expect? This insomniac billionaire who can only sleep when I'm in his arms. What he didn't expect? That his convenient arrangement would become his obsession.
In daylight, he's a master of indifference—his gaze sliding past me like I don't exist. But when darkness falls, he's pushing up my lace dress, his hands claiming my breasts through the sheer material, his mouth finding the small mole on my collarbone.
"That's it," he breathes against my skin, voice strained and gravelly. "God, you feel amazing."
Now the lines are blurred, the stakes are higher, and everyone who betrayed me is about to learn what happens when you underestimate Aria Harper.
Revenge never felt so good.
The MC President’s Runaway
Controlling. Violent. Obsessed.
The night he tried to kill her, Rina disappeared.
With nothing but the clothes on her back and a fake name, she flees halfway across the country, landing in the unforgiving deserts of New Mexico. Broke and desperate, she takes a job dancing at the Devil’s Den, a notorious strip club where cash is king and questions aren’t asked.
She swears she’ll leave the moment she saves enough money.
Then Max Torres walks through the door.
As the ruthless president of the Sons of Doom Motorcycle Club, Max has spent years building a brotherhood feared across the Southwest. He doesn’t mix business with women, and he definitely doesn’t get involved with strippers.
Until Rina.
The beautiful dancer with haunted eyes is hiding something, and every instinct tells Max she’s in danger. When the man hunting her finally tracks her down, he’ll discover one brutal truth.
Rina Blakely may have run from one monster…
But now she’s under the protection of an even more dangerous one.
The Spy Who Left
"I still can't believe she actually did it. Aria Hart, filing for divorce. Who saw that coming?"
"How long do we think it'll take before she comes crawling back?" Another voice joins the conversation.
"Three days," Victoria declares. "Five at most. She has no money, no skills, no family. Where's she going to go?"
When Aria Chen divorced billionaire Leon Hart, New York's elite sneered, betting she'd crawl back within days. She never did.
Three years later, the world is rocked when Dr. Aria Vale, CEO of a revolutionary cybersecurity empire, steps into the spotlight. The mysterious genius who built a billion-dollar company from nothing is none other than Leon's discarded wife, the woman everyone thought was just a pretty ornament.
Now, every powerful man wants the queen Leon threw away a renowned scientist seeking partnership, a financial titan proposing an empire, and an actor offering devotion. Each sees the brilliance Leon ignored.
Then Leon discovers the truth: Aria's sacrifices, her secret double life, and the daughter she's been raising without him. For the first time, the man who once took her for granted must fight for her love. But can he compete with men who valued her from the beginning?
A story of love, betrayal, and power where the king must kneel before the queen who never needed saving.
Ravens MC Series; Marlowe & Torin-Book 2 (Bad Boys Collections)
Marlowe Mills thought the hard part was surviving the enemies who wanted to destroy her. She was wrong.
The real damage came from the people she loved most. A buried secret. A devastating betrayal. A truth everyone knew except her.
Now the man she loves must prove that protecting someone isn't the same as lying to them, while she struggles to decide whether trust, once shattered, can ever truly be rebuilt. Because love was never the problem. Trust was.
The Family Books 1-3 (A Mafia romance)
The saint to my sinner. with her innocent eyes and devilish curves.
A Madonna that was meant to be admired but never touched.
Until someone took that innocence from her.
She left.
The darkness in my heart was finally complete.
I avenged her, I killed for her, but she never came back.
Until I saw her again. An angel dancing around a pole for money.
She didn’t know I owned that club. She didn’t know I was watching.
This time I won’t let her escape.
I will make her back into the girl I knew.
Whether she likes it or not.
2/ Judge and Jury- I can’t stop watching her.
I’m not even sure I want to.
Taylor Lawson, blonde, beautiful, and totally oblivious to how much dangers she’s in.
She’s also the one juror in my upcoming murder trial that hasn’t been bought.
The one who can put me behind bars for a very long time.
I know I should execute her.
After all that’s what I do.
I am the Judge.
I eliminate threats to The Family.
And Taylor is a threat.
But I don’t want to kill her.
Possessing her, making her love me seems like a much better plan for this particular Juror.
3/ Rags and Ritches-
The Three of Us
WILLIAM BELINNI — THE DON'S FORBIDDEN BRIDE — Book Three
Rebecca Windsor was born a mafia princess and raised to obey.
At eighteen, her future is already decided. She has a respectable fiancé, a powerful family, and a marriage arranged for convenience. She should be grateful.
Then she meets the one man she was never supposed to want.
William Belinni is the heir to the Chicago Outfit—a ruthless, unpredictable man preparing to inherit his father's empire. He doesn't want love. He doesn't want marriage. He certainly doesn't want a woman already promised to someone else.
But when he finds Rebecca crying alone in the darkness of his private garden, something changes.
She doesn't know who he is.
He doesn't tell her.
One conversation becomes an obsession. One stolen moment becomes a temptation neither can escape.
Rebecca has spent her entire life believing her destiny belongs to her family.
William has spent his life taking whatever he wants.
And now he wants her.
But in the mafia, broken engagements are more than scandals. They are threats to power, loyalty, and blood.
If William claims the woman promised to another man, he could ignite a war between their families.
And Rebecca may finally have to decide whether she will continue living the life chosen for her...
or risk everything for the man who makes her want to choose for herself.












