I Kissed The Wrong Twin, Now What?

I Kissed The Wrong Twin, Now What?

Kave Derry · Ongoing · 186.2k Words

323
Hot
324
Views
0
Added
Add to Shelf
Start Reading
Share:facebooktwitterpinterestwhatsappreddit

Introduction

All Kimberly Callahan wanted was one unforgettable night with the boy she secretly adored—Jason Travolta. What she never expected, however… was to kiss his twin brother. 

A stolen moment behind a mask. A forbidden kiss that tasted too perfect to regret—until a scandalous photo spread across campus, making headlines among the crowd. Now Kimberly finds herself trapped in a fake relationship with Jett Travolta, the twin she was never supposed to touch.

To make matters worse, her mother has just married their father.

Living under the same roof as the Travolta twins was never a part of her plan. Loving one and loathing the other should’ve been easy—until the blurred lines turned into a dangerous spark. 

One kiss changed everything.

Now, she was trapped between two brothers and every step she took brought them closer to dangerous attraction and affections.

But the real question is:

Was it ever truly a mistake… or fate in disguise?

Chapter 1

CHAPTER 1

Kim's Pov

I knew I should have stayed home. But Mitchell swore this party would change everything I had hoped for—that Wellington’s annual masked ball was the one that I had waited for and couldn’t afford to miss.

I hated the idea of a loud, sweaty party and people pretending to be what they are not so much that it made my skin crawl. Yet here I was, playing along… all for the chance to finally catch the attention of my long-time crush.

“Finally,” I muttered, taking a sip of wine. I looked at Mitchell, her wild eyes sparkling with anticipation, waiting to see how I'd approach the one thing that had brought me to the masked party.

With a deep breath, I adjusted my mask and walked towards him—the gentleman I had been hopelessly drawn to since high school. His broad chest and sculpted abs were on sight, covered with a well-tailored suit, and even under the dim light, his sharp eyes tracked my steps as I moved closer—

I paused mid-step, suddenly uncertain. Mitchell saw the mask, didn't she? I took my phone out and texted her; the pounding music around was enough to devour every word we might speak.

ME: Hey, what mask did you say he was wearing again?

I pressed the send button, and she looked up at me. She smiled knowingly before texting back.

MITCHELL: He's right in front of you, with the dark purple mask, and he's in a white suit, too. Be careful, talk to him nicely.

My phone buzzed and I read the message before taking a deep breath.

Right. Jason Travolta. Star forward. Campus legend. My one-sided crush for the last two years… And tonight… maybe my chance.

I scanned the crowd and spotted him. He stood across the dance floor, leaning against the railing. One hand in his pocket, the other loosely holding a drink he clearly wasn’t interested in. His gaze lingered on me again, and I finally got closer. Well, enough not to look creepy.

My stomach flipped as soon as he looked closely at me.

Mitchell gave me a shove and urged me. “Go say hi.”

I didn’t think it would be that easy.

Jason’s lips curved into the faintest smirk. “Thought it was high time you came to me,” he said, his voice low, teasing and far too confident.

“What?”

He stepped in close—too close. His cologne wrapped around me, dizzying.

“I’ve been at this party all night,” he murmured, “and I haven't seen any stare at me as much as you have.”

My cheeks felt like they were burning. “Oh… that. I'm so sorry. I just really liked your mask. I didn't realize you were watching too. I was just too caught up with my friend, you know…”

His smile deepened. “So, how's the party going?”

I never imagined Jason would be interested in talking to me; he had never even looked my way when I walked around or showed up.

“My friend brought me here,” I admitted, then blurted. “Can I ask you something?”

He nodded in approval.

“Do you… know who I am?” I asked.

His head tilted slightly. “You’re in a mask, but I'm sure you already know who I am.”

“Yeah,” I whispered. “You're Jason. Forgive me for this—”

Before I could lose my nerve, I hastily leaned in and kissed him. It was reckless. I didn’t want to, but I did. Just one kiss was what I had expected to make him know I was in love with him.

I pulled back to catch my breath, but his hands closed around my waist, pulling me flush against him.

His lips brushed against mine—slow, deliberate, devastating. I responded like I had been waiting forever. He tasted like trouble, something I never expected would satisfy me so much. My fingers curled into his jacket, my heart racing in its rhythm. He cupped my jaw with such care, like I was something fragile. At that moment, my heart forgot how to beat.

When he finally released me, he tugged off his mask, a smile tugging at his lips. “You taste really sweet, princess.”

My eyes widened. “Oh my god.”

“What was that?” he teased.

“I just kissed you and you kissed me back.” My voice came out half-squeal, half gasp.

“Yes, I did.” He answered.

“Did you know I was in love with you?” I blurted.

Before he could answer, another voice cut in—familiar, sharp.

“Jett? I'm taking the car home. Find your own ride home.”

I froze. Slowly, I turned—only to see another Jason standing close to me.

The real Jason.

My heart sank.

“Oh my God,” I breathed and shoved the man in front of me, panic rising in my chest. “You’re not Jason!?”

“You never asked who I was.” He said, a smirk curling on the corner of his lips.

Behind us, the real Jason watched, more confused and less concerned, like he had always been.

Gosh! I didn’t kiss Jason! I just kissed Jett.

I was never meant to kiss Jett. I should have known it wasn't him. Jason never looked at me; he was never the one to talk much.

The truth hit me like a punch. I looked at the mark on Jett's neck; Jason didn’t have it.

I had made such a huge mistake.

Mortified, I spun on my heel and bolted, feeling embarrassed and tears dripping from my eyes.

“I kissed Jett. It was Jett, and not Jason, Mitchell.” My voice broke as I buried my face in my hands. “I think I've made a mistake.”

Mitchell, already half drunk, wasn’t the best audience right now, and it only made it all worse to cry right beside her.

I fled to the bathroom, desperate to wash it all away—my tears, my face and that kiss. To forget everything that happened.

“He knew I never wanted to kiss him, and he still kissed me back! Such a jerk!” I hissed, scrubbing my face aggressively like it would erase the memory.

Numerous thoughts spun through my head, dizzying and sharp.

‘Did Jason see that? Is that why he showed up? To see who his brother was kissing?’

I brushed my lips, the kiss replaying as a scene in my head with cruel detail. He tasted better than I ever imagined, but it was still a mistake.

“Don't tell me you regret taking a bold step.”

I froze upon hearing the voice. Jett leaned against the doorway, all cocky. “It's just a kiss. You'll be fine. No one cares.”

“I care, okay?” My voice cracked. “You just ruined two years of my life's preparation. In fact, you just ruined my whole life.”

His brows lifted as he smirked. “Wait—I ruined it? You kissed me.”

“And you kissed me back!” My throat tightened. “I thought you were Jason. I was only in love with Jason, and I never meant to kiss you, and you… you knew that! You jerk!”

“I didn’t stop you because it was written all over your face,” he said, a little too amused.

“I hate you.”

“Come on—it was just a kiss.”

My jaw ached from how hard I was clenching it. “You could’ve stopped me.”

“But you didn’t want me to,” he replied smoothly.

I hated that he was right.

I hated that I could still feel his lips on mine, like an aftertaste I couldn’t spit out. Like a dream I wasn’t ready to wake from.

Without another word, I pushed past him. The party didn’t stop just because I was having a bad day.

I stood at the edge of it all for a moment, frozen in thought, the memory of that kiss hitting me again and again every few seconds like a slap.

My chest burned, I hated how it all turned out, so I turned to the only thing that could numb me—alcohol.

Mitchell was busy having fun better than I expected; she didn't see how messed up I was.

The liquor burned its way down my throat, warm and numbing, helping me forget the way Jett’s lips had felt and how firm his hands had been.

I ignored him all night. If Jett glanced my way, I turned. If he lingered nearby, I left. I tried every way to ignore everything that happened, beating myself up each time I remembered I kissed Jett, knowing Jason had probably seen it all.

“This is the end,” I whispered into my glass. “I'm never getting Jason ever again! Not now, not ever. I'm totally toast.”

Last Chapters

You Might Like 😍

Bound by the Dragon Mafia

Bound by the Dragon Mafia

6.5k Views · Ongoing · McKenzie Shinabery
“No, no, no,” she said, pointing at a platter. “If it’s called ‘Goth Girl French Toast,’ then it has to be black. I don’t care how you do it. Activated charcoal. Blackberries. Food coloring. Demon blood. Whatever.”

The head chef looked like he was silently praying for death.

I rushed forward. “Amara. Stop traumatizing these poor people.”

She spun around, delighted. “Sera! Good, you’re here. Taste this. It’s missing despair.”

The chef’s face morphed into existential crisis.

I grabbed her arm. “Put the spatula down.”

“But—”

“Down.”

With exaggerated offense, she dropped the spatula and muttered, “Fine. But if no one here has artistic vision, that’s not my fault.”

She went undercover to expose a mafia empire.
He offered her thirty nights to save her life.

When investigative journalist Seraphine Vale steps into the glittering underworld ruled by billionaire crime lord Dante Vescari, she thinks she’s chasing a story about missing women and corruption.
Instead, she uncovers a secret older than blood—an empire built on fire, sin, and dragons.

Bound to Dante by a forbidden pact, Seraphine finds herself caught between fear and desire, truth and temptation.
Each night pulls her deeper into his world of power, passion, and danger…
and closer to the monster hiding beneath his perfect skin.

Thirty nights. One bond.
And a love that might just burn the world to ash.
Timeless Us

Timeless Us

1.8k Views · Ongoing · Jennifer Cooper
A strange traffic jam hurls Chloe twenty-three years into the future.
The world she knew is gone.
Her husband, Nathan, is no longer the young man she left behind—he’s successful, respected, and living with a new family.
But when the woman who disappeared twenty-three years ago suddenly returns…
can love survive the years that were lost?
The Vampire Prince's Hybrid Bride

The Vampire Prince's Hybrid Bride

46.3k Views · Ongoing · Riley Above Story
As a wolfless orphan, Joanne had been abused by Alpha Anthony ever since she was a child. She devoted her entire life to surviving in his pack—until one day, she returned home to find an injured vampire lying in her house, his whole existence luring her in. Taking the risk of bringing him in, Joanne never expected Alpha Anthony to discover it the very next day and finally seize the chance to kill her. Just as Joanne was about to be executed, the vampire she had saved arrived, with his army. And Joanne realized that he was the Prince Alexander, heir to the vampire throne…..
A TASTE OF TEMPTATION: Vampire King And His Hybrid Bride

A TASTE OF TEMPTATION: Vampire King And His Hybrid Bride

2k Views · Completed · The Guitarist
A ruthless vampire king, a hidden hybrid, and a centuries-old secret ignite a forbidden love amidst a brewing war.

Chained and rejected by my pack, I thought I was just an ordinary werewolf. But the Vampire King's rescue reveals my true nature and a shocking past. Now, as shifters and vampires clash, I must choose between my heritage and my destiny.

Will I surrender to the King's dark desires, or forge my own path? In this world of ancient power struggles, one thing is certain: my blood will decide the fate of all.
Taming Her Playboy Bully

Taming Her Playboy Bully

4.8k Views · Ongoing · Jane Lexington
Benjamin Halesten has a huge problem. His father has threatened to cut him off from his lavish lifestyle unless he agrees to see the mysterious Mrs. Black at an elite life coach agency. At the consultation, Mrs. Black lays out the plan. It’s simple: abide by the rules, or Benjamin loses everything. The plan, one of Mrs. Black’s ‘Gem girls’, is to pose as his girlfriend while straightening up his life and public appearance. Benjamin reluctantly agrees, but he is floored when he meets his life coach. Meet the brilliant Dr. Lainey Forest, who has killer curves, a kind soul, and a mesmerizing personality. Benjamin falls for her instantly, not recognizing her as someone from his past. With every minute, every public display of affection, Benjamin is losing himself in Lainey. Lainey, on the other hand, battles with the pure hatred she has towards Benjamin and the slow-growing love that is building in her heart for him. Can Lainey put the past aside to find true love, or are they bound to both end up with broken hearts?
COLD (Ruthless Player)

COLD (Ruthless Player)

10.1k Views · Completed · A. K Adam
“Was she the one who sent you?” he growled “Did she pay you to whore yourself to me?”
“Please… Nick, wait.” He pulled out, thrusted back in. “How much? Twenty thousand? Fifty? Hundred?” With every question, he thrust harder and harder. My neurons are frying with the confusing feeling in my brain. Torn between pleasure, fear, and panic. I couldn't utter a single sentence to save my life.

His cold eyes pinned me in place while he plundered my body with deep thrusts, which only added to my confusion. My dumb body mistook the mixed signals, my pussy becoming even wetter than before.

“I hope she'd paid you well, because I'm going to fuck you all night long, hard,” he growled. “Sleep, then do it all over again. I want to feel you come for me, Andrea, want to feel you squeeze my cock, milking me.

Begging for me to give you the high only I can, I'm going to fucked you until I fuck all my wife's money's worth, I want you to remember how hard I took you while you're meeting her.” I sobbed, moaned, and tried to scramble out under him.

“No, please…Nick, let….let me explain.” Nick abruptly pulled out. His eyes were cold but hooded.


Andrea was sent to take down billionaire magnate Nicklaus Montgomery.
Her mission was simple: get close, seduce him, find the proof, and disappear. Instead Andrea finds herself exposed—cornered into signing a contract that binds her to Nicklaus's side as his lover. Now she’s living in his world of wealth, danger, and secrets… and the deeper she falls into his bed, the harder it becomes to remember what side she's on.
Death By Breathing

Death By Breathing

4.6k Views · Completed · arianniahrain
After a deadly virus shattered civilization, a new world rose from the ruins—one ruled by Alphas.

Females are claimed. Controlled. Bred.

Alex swore she would die before becoming any man’s possession.

Fiercely independent and determined to escape the fate forced on women like her, Alex has spent years surviving under the radar. But everything changes when the powerful Vandicoff brothers—three ruthless Alpha rulers—discover she is their true mate.

The moment they claim her, war ignites.

Alex refuses to submit to their bond, their authority, or the dangerous pull between them. She fights every command, every touch, every instinct threatening to drag her under. But the more she resists, the more obsessed the brothers become.

What begins as a battle for control soon sends shockwaves through the entire Alpha world, threatening the Vandicoff empire itself.

Can Alex survive three possessive Alphas without losing herself in the process?

Or will the one thing she craves most—love—become the very thing that destroys her?
Cursed Beauty and her Three Alpha Mates

Cursed Beauty and her Three Alpha Mates

4.6k Views · Ongoing · Author Aimen
“I am Maya Blackthorn, the first daughter of Alpha Darius of the Ashbourne Pack, and I am damned… damned by the Moon Goddess. And destined to bring kingdoms to their knees.”
Cast out by her pack for being wolfless and plagued by uncontrollable heat, Maya has spent her life surviving humiliation in silence.
Fate drags her into the path of Kael Draven, the ruthless Lycan King who claims her… only to reject her.
But Kael is not the only Alpha bound to her.
Finn, her childhood best friend and the rising Alpha, loves her with a devotion so fierce, he spends four years locked away in the most ruthless dungeon only to keep her safe.
Xander, a rogue wolf who can make even Alphas bow to his will, has waited centuries for her to be reborn, and he has no intention of losing her again.
Three Alphas.
Three claims.
One cursed destiny.
They called her wolfless. They thought she was weak. But she is done hiding, and this time, she's rewriting the rules.
After the Divorce She Became Untouchable

After the Divorce She Became Untouchable

2.5k Views · Ongoing · Anais SwiftPen
On her wedding anniversary, Annabelle Whitmore meticulously planned a surprise. However, she drank a drugged drink given to her by her stepsister. When she awoke, she was in a strange man's bed. Photos of her surfaced online instantly, and her reputation was utterly destroyed.

Her husband, Abel Donovan, a ruthless and powerful figure, gave her no chance to defend herself, readily believing his stepsister's lies.

Anna was pregnant with his child and was cruelly driven away.

Five years later, Annabelle was no longer the infamous, abandoned woman she once was. She returned as the CEO of the global fashion empire BelleNova.

Abel never imagined she would return, especially with his child.
Game of Destiny

Game of Destiny

1.2m Views · Completed · Dripping Creativity
Amie's wolf hasn't shown herself. But who cares? She has a good pack, best friends and a family who loves her. Everyone, including the Alpha, is telling her she is perfect just the way she is. That is until she finds her mate and he rejects her. Heartbroken Amie flees from everything and start over. No more werewolves, no more packs.

When Finlay finds her, she is living among humans. He is smitten by the stubborn wolf that refuse to acknowledge his existence. She may not be his mate, but he wants her to be a part of his pack, latent wolf or not.

Amie cant resist the Alpha that comes into her life and drags her back into pack life. Not only does she find herself happier than she has been in a long time, her wolf finally comes to her. Finlay isn't her mate, but he becomes her best friend. Together with the other top wolves in the pack, they work to create the best and strongest pack.

When it's time for the pack games, the event that decides the packs rank for the coming ten year, Amie needs to face her old pack. When she sees the man that rejected her for the first time in ten years, everything she thought she knew is turned around. Amie and Finlay need to adapt to the new reality and find a way forward for their pack. But will the curve ball split them apart?
What the Heart Wants (Book 1 of the Alpha Faros Series)

What the Heart Wants (Book 1 of the Alpha Faros Series)

2.8k Views · Ongoing · FM Publishing
Loving him will cost them everything…

Not loving him will cost more.

Derek has one goal: survive high school without drawing too much attention or pissing off his pack’s alpha.

As the youngest son of the alpha, his life is governed by lycan hierarchy, tradition, and politics. With no signs of awakening a lycan spirit, his only value is what he can do for the pack’s image. He knows he’s only ever one misstep away from exile… or worse.

Then, he finds a boy trapped in a locker on orientation day, and everything changes.

Derek shouldn’t want Nikolias. He’s off-limits. A risk Derek can’t afford.

So why does it feel like he’s the only thing worth fighting for?

Nikolias has just lost everything: his parents, his home, and any sense of peace. Sent back to the town his family left years ago to live with his prejudiced and controlling uncle, who wants nothing to do with anything—or anyone—not human, he’s trying to do everything in his power to get out quickly.

But then he meets Derek again, and all of his plans vanish in the soft, yearning flecks of gold in Derek’s green-hazel eyes. He’s drawn to Derek in a way that’s impossible to deny, and he thinks Derek feels the same way, despite the danger their relationship holds for him.

As Moonshadow's politics turn deadly, Derek and Nikolai are caught in the crossfire of a war that had started long before they were born, and their bond becomes a threat and a lifeline that neither can afford to sever.

Because the heart wants what it wants….

And it never asks permission.

TW: Graphic Violence, Suicide Ideation, Suicide Attempt, Child Abuse, Cult-Like Behavior