He Married My Sister, Now He Wants Me Back

He Married My Sister, Now He Wants Me Back

Zara Thorne · Completed · 9.6k Words

261
Hot
276
Views
0
Added
Add to Shelf
Start Reading
Share:facebooktwitterpinterestwhatsappreddit

Introduction

In my first life, my husband blamed me for my sister’s death, and my family never defended me. Then we both woke up in the past. This time, Julian chose my sister. My parents shipped me off to Chicago to marry an aging mafia Don. They waited for me to beg. Instead, I packed my bags. On his wedding day, Julian realized I was leaving for good. I was done explaining. Done chasing their approval. He got the second chance he begged for. I got something far better — a life that was mine.

Chapter 1

I died carrying blame that was never mine.

They laid every one of Camila's misfortunes at my feet.

Julian's hatred, my parents' cold bargain, crushed down heavy on my bones.

Then I woke up. Back to this night, the night they sealed my fate. I only had three days. Three days before I was sent to Chicago, traded as a bride to a dying man for an alliance.

Julian carried the same memories as me. This time, he would choose Camila without hesitation.

He would say my suffering should not be a weight on her happiness. Once, I begged him to see me, hoping someone would choose me. Not this time. I would take the path they set for me.

I would go to Chicago. But I would not break. I would not beg. I would never come back to them.


As the banquet drew to a close, Mother cornered me. The moisture glistening in her eyes was orchestrated to perfection.

"Elena, I knew you'd understand," she said. "You've always known how to see the bigger picture."

I said nothing. In my previous life, as I lay bleeding out on the cold floor, a messenger had come to tell her I couldn't hold on much longer. Instead of rushing to the hospital, she had chosen to stay at this exact kind of family gala, never once stepping away to see me.

Camila approached. Across the grand hall, Julian was engaged in a hushed conversation with Father.

"I'm so sorry, Elena," she murmured, her voice dialed down to a whisper as the corners of her eyes instantly flushed red. "Mom told me about the Chicago arrangement. If you didn't have to take my place, you wouldn't be forced to suffer like this."

Eighteen years ago, a rival syndicate attempted to assassinate the Valenti family. During the desperate flight, my parents grabbed Camila and rushed into a safe house, leaving me entirely forgotten in the backseat of the car. The enemy snatched me, realized I held no ransom value, and tossed me into the most vicious, crime-ridden slums of Brooklyn. An Asian woman who washed dishes in Chinatown found me and raised me as her own.

Five years ago, as the Valenti empire suffered a string of crushing losses, they suddenly needed two daughters to secure underground alliances across two cities. Only then did they remember I existed. Had it not been for their own greed and survival, they would have happily left me for dead.

Camila covered her mouth, letting out a delicate, wounded sob.

Hearing her distress, Julian crossed the room and pulled her protectively into his arms.

"What's wrong?"

She leaned against his expensive tailored suit, shaking her head. "I just don't want Elena to hate me because of this."

"Don't cry, baby. This isn't your fault." He pressed a kiss to her hair. But when his gaze shifted to me, every ounce of that tenderness vanished, replaced by a chilling disgust. "I've made my choice. Don't force your misfortune to become Camila's burden."

Mother approached with a flute of champagne, dabbing at the corner of her eye.

"Today should be a celebration. Camila finally gets to marry the man she loves, and our families will be united."

Father and Julian began discussing the wedding date. Only moments later did Father spare a glance in my direction, looking at me as if he had just realized I was standing there.

"Julian, regarding Elena's arrangement—"

"Julian, you promised to help me pick out my wedding band." Camila slipped her hand into his, her voice honey-sweet. "The jeweler is already waiting on the terrace."

Julian's expression instantly melted into warmth. "Alright. Let's go."

Without waiting for Father to finish, she pulled Julian away. The heavy glass doors of the terrace clicked shut behind them.

Father turned back to me. "Camila's wedding is set for three days from now. Elena, you will leave for Chicago on that exact same day. The old Don of the Morettis has given his nod. You'll be married to him by nightfall."

Mother feigned hesitation. "Won't that be a bit too harsh on Elena?"

Father let out a low chuckle, rolling a thick cigar between his fingers. "Her future husband is the Don of the Chicago Moretti family. He's riddled with sickness and barely has long to live, but the territory, dirty money, and raw power in his grip are beyond imagination." He looked at me, forcing a sickeningly sweet smile. "Elena, Daddy is truly happy for you."

The murmurs of family elders and guests drifted into my ears.

"The one in Chicago? Word is, his hands are soaked in blood debts."

"He's nearly seventy, clinging to life on a ventilator."

"Poor Elena. Barely back home for five years, and she's already being used as a bargaining chip."

In my past life, hearing those whispers would have sent me hiding in the bathroom, breaking down into uncontrollable sobs.

This time, my face remained perfectly blank. I picked up my glass of red wine and took a slow, deliberate sip.

As it was time to leave, Julian and Camila walked ahead. My parents followed closely behind them, excitedly discussing the lavish arrangements for the upcoming wedding. No one noticed that I had fallen far behind.

Julian pulled open the heavy door of the bulletproof Rolls-Royce, leaning down to smooth out Camila's dress before gently shielding her as she climbed in. Camila tilted her head back and pressed a lingering kiss to his cheek.

"Seeing how much Julian dotes on her, we can finally rest easy," Father said, patting Mother's hand before sliding into the pristine leather seats.

It played out exactly like my past life. Not a single person looked back at me.

I glanced down at the evening gown I wore. The hem was far too long, dragging heavily against the rough asphalt—it was an old, out-of-season piece that Camila had grown tired of. Mother had claimed that altering it would be a waste of money, insisting I should just wear her hand-me-downs. Throughout the banquet, every socialite had praised Camila for her generosity in lending such expensive gowns to her older sister. Naturally, no one ever bothered to ask if I actually wanted to wear someone else's discarded clothes.

Julian shut the car door and finally noticed me lingering in the shadows. He frowned and strode over, his posture dripping with condescension.

"Elena, there's no need to put on that face," he said coldly. "Even if I marry Camila, it's not like no one will accept you. Once the marriage is settled, the drama will blow over. You'll get used to it."

He was absolutely certain I would stay, quietly swallowing down every ounce of my humiliation.

"I understand," I replied, my voice deadpan.

Julian studied me, a fleeting shadow of unease crossing his eyes. The old Elena would have cried. She would have fought. She would have begged.

After a brief, loaded silence, he turned around and got into the car. The motorcade pulled out in sequence, quickly swallowed by the pitch-black night.

My phone buzzed in my clutch. A text message lit up the screen:

[We forgot you weren't in the car. Just call an Uber back.]

The 'me' from my past life had long grown accustomed to being abandoned.

Arriving back at the family estate alone, I found Camila waiting for me in the grand living room, a massive diamond gleaming heavily on her ring finger.

"Elena, right after you walked away, Julian officially proposed to me. He said he was so grateful that fate gave him the chance to choose again." She rubbed the face of the diamond, entirely unable to hide the triumphant gleam in her eyes. "Thank you for letting us be together."

I offered a faint, hollow smile, said nothing, and turned to head upstairs to my room.

Camila's triumphant words only confirmed what I already knew. Julian had chosen her, exactly as he had in our past life.

The bedroom door clicked shut behind me. My eyes drifted to the half-packed suitcase sitting in the corner.

I only had three days left before I could escape this blood-soaked cage.

This time, I would go to Chicago exactly as they wished. And I would never come back.

Last Chapters

You Might Like 😍

The CEO Above My Desk

The CEO Above My Desk

696.3k Views · Completed · McKenzie Shinabery
“You think she needs you,” he says.

“I know she does.”

“And what if she doesn’t want this kind of protection?”

“She will,” I say, my voice lowering slightly. “Because she needs a man who can give her the world.”

“And if the world burns?”

My hand tightens subtly at Violet’s waist.

“Then I’ll build her a new one,” I reply. “Even if I have to burn the old one down myself.”

I don’t work for Rowan Ashcroft.
I work beneath him.

From my desk, I decide who gets access to the most ruthless CEO in the city, and who never makes it past the lobby. I manage his time, his silence, his enemies. I keep his world running while my own quietly collapses under unpaid bills, a mother locked in rehab, and a brother who vanished without a goodbye.

Rowan Ashcroft is power wrapped in a tailored suit.
Cold. Untouchable. Merciless.
He doesn’t flirt. He doesn’t smile. He doesn’t see people, only usefulness.

And for a long time, I was just useful.

Until he started watching.

A shift in his attention is subtle at first. A pause too long. A look that lingers. Orders that pull me closer instead of pushing me away. The man who stands above my desk begins to control more than my schedule, and I realize too late that being noticed by Rowan Ashcroft is far more dangerous than being ignored.

Because men like him don’t crave affection.
They crave possession.

This was supposed to be a job.
Not a test of my limits.
Not a slow, deliberate descent into his authority.

But if Rowan Ashcroft decides I belong under his desk, then so be it.
Survival has a price, and the bills don’t care how I pay them.
The Alpha King's Human Mate

The Alpha King's Human Mate

472k Views · Completed · HC Dolores
“You must understand something, little mate,” Griffin said, and his face softened,

“I have waited nine years for you. That’s nearly a decade since I’ve felt this emptiness inside me. Part of me began to wonder if you didn’t exist or you’d already died. And then I found you, right inside my own home.” 

He used one of his hands to stroke my cheek and tingles erupted everywhere. 

“I’ve spent enough time without you and I will not let anything else keep us apart. Not other wolves, not my drunken father who’s barely holding himself together the past twenty years, not your family  – and not even you.”


Clark Bellevue has spent her entire life as the only human in the wolf pack - literally. Eighteen years ago, Clark was the accidental result of a brief affair between one of the most powerful Alphas in the world and a human woman. Despite living with her father and her werewolf half-siblings, Clark has never felt like she really belonged in the werewolf world. But right as Clark plans to leave the werewolf world behind for good, her life gets flipped upside down by her mate: the next Alpha King, Griffin Bardot. Griffin has been waiting years for the chance to meet his mate, and he's not about to let her go anytime soon. It doesn't matter how far Clark tries to run from her destiny or her mate - Griffin intends to keep her, no matter what he has to do or who stands in his way.
Luna On The Run- I stole The Alpha's Sons

Luna On The Run- I stole The Alpha's Sons

147.8k Views · Completed · Jessica Hall
Elena was born to lead, but her father strips her of her birthright and gives it to her younger brother. Desperate to get back at her father, she does the unthinkable: she sleeps with her father's greatest enemy, Alpha Axton.

But Axton is more than just a rival, he's her fated mate. And he's been searching for her not for love, but for revenge and a chance to destroy her father's pack. The next morning, Elena rejects him, walking away before he can trap her in his ruthless schemes.

But Axton does not take rejection lightly, and his retaliation is brutal: a leaked video, a ruined reputation, and a family that turns their backs on her drive her to flee the city in disgrace.

But when Elena disappears, she takes something Alpha Axton never planned to lose - his sons. Now, he'll stop at nothing to get them back. He wants his heirs, he wants his mate, and Elena will learn that no one runs from the Alpha.
Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

Bonds at War: The Virgin is Mine

2.9k Views · Ongoing · Sand Kastle
ARDEN: I always thought getting accepted into Elite Order Academy would finally make my family proud.
Perhaps then they would stop controlling my every move. Maybe my brothers would stop resenting me. Perhaps I wouldn’t feel so invisible anymore.
No one believed I could do it—not even my mate, Alpha Jaxon Trevane.
The night I planned to tell him... I found him tangled in bed with my best friend.
Heartbroken and humiliated, I left everything behind and went to Elite alone.
But the academy isn’t the fairytale I dreamed about.
Beneath the grand halls and traditions, a brutal game is being played.
The four ruling Alphas of the North, South, East, and West fight for power, dominance... and now, for me.
A virgin. Untouched. Unclaimed. The prize they all want.
There’s the mate who shattered my heart and swears he’ll win me back.
The brilliant strategist who wants me as his Luna.
The dangerous playboy who promises no one will ever touch me but him.
And the cold, possessive Alpha who watches from the shadows—and would destroy anyone who dares to take me from him.
But in a place where love is a battlefield and lust is a weapon... falling in love might be the most dangerous thing I ever do.
Welcome to Elite Order Academy—where every desire has a price, and my body is the ultimate trophy.
The rejected white luna

The rejected white luna

9.5k Views · Completed · gabrielgladys37
Aria was the daughter of the Alpha of the Silver moon pack born into a life of strength and legacy but instead of respect, she is overlooked by the members of her own pack due to her weak wolf. She had always wanted to have a mate just like everyone else but on the night of the mating ceremony, her dreams came crashing down when her own mate rejects her publicly choosing another.Aria is left humiliated but something inside her refuses to stay broken. As tension rises and unseen forces begin to shift, Aria starts to realize there may be more to her than anyone ever believed and when Aria stumbled on another pack and found out he is her second chance mate. Aria is stunned especially when she finds out who he is. what happens when Aria finds out that her second chance mate who she thought loves her was working for the Lycan king? And somehow finds herself in his kingdom? Would she be weighed down by betrayal? Or would she come out strong? What happens when she found out her fated mate who had rejected her wants her back? Would she go to him ? Or forgive her second chance mate?
Small Town and Star Crossed

Small Town and Star Crossed

1.1k Views · Ongoing · A.J Andrew’s
Asley had grown up all her life knowing three things: she loved her family, this was a small town, and Gavin Attlage was bad news. A long-standing family feud already separated the two, not to mention he had been expelled for fighting her brother, but now they worked together. The whole town gossiped about his exploits and her breakup, it seemed like fate that they found themselves in close proximity. With football season looming and Gavin the star quarterback of the opposing team, Ashley can't help but start to cheer for him. There's a fine line between love and hate,e and these two seem to tumble right over the edge.
Omega Bound

Omega Bound

2.9m Views · Completed · Veronica White
Ayla Frost is a beautiful, rare omega. Kidnapped, tortured, and trafficked to rogue clans and corrupt alphas to do with as they pleased.  Kept alive in her cage, broken and abandoned by her wolf, she becomes mute and has given up on hope for a better life until one explosion changes everything. 

Thane Knight is the alpha of the Midnight Pack of the La Plata Mountain Range, the largest wolf shifter pack in the world. He is an alpha by day and hunts the shifter trafficking ring with his group of mercenaries by night. His hunt for vengeance leads to one raid that changes his life. 

Tropes:
Touch her and die/Slow burn romance/Fated Mates/Found family twist/Close circle betrayal/Cinnamon roll for only her/Traumatized heroine/Rare wolf/Hidden powers/Knotting/Nesting/Heats/Luna/Attempted assassination
Cue the Dark

Cue the Dark

1.5k Views · Ongoing · lanre23231
Wren Castellane takes the stage manager job at the Regatta Playhouse to outrun a failed marriage and a stalled career, not to reopen a cold case. But the theater hasn't staged “The Drowning Room” since 1994, the night its leading lady walked into the tide and never came back. Reviving the play for the theater's centenary means working under Julian Voss, the owner's grandson, a man who canceled every production of that script for thirty years and won't say why. As opening night approaches, someone starts leaving Wren notes in the dead woman's handwriting, moving props between rehearsals, humming her exact vocal warm-up in the wings when the building's empty. Julian knows more than he's telling. So does the theater's aging costumer, who flinches every time the drowned actress's name comes up. Wren has three weeks to get the show up — and to find out whether she's staging a play or walking into someone else's unfinished ending
The Spy Who Left

The Spy Who Left

2.2k Views · Completed · Orion Vale
"She's naive. A pretty little socialite who got lucky marrying above her station."
"I still can't believe she actually did it. Aria Hart, filing for divorce. Who saw that coming?"
"How long do we think it'll take before she comes crawling back?" Another voice joins the conversation.
"Three days," Victoria declares. "Five at most. She has no money, no skills, no family. Where's she going to go?"
When Aria Chen divorced billionaire Leon Hart, New York's elite sneered, betting she'd crawl back within days. She never did.
Three years later, the world is rocked when Dr. Aria Vale, CEO of a revolutionary cybersecurity empire, steps into the spotlight. The mysterious genius who built a billion-dollar company from nothing is none other than Leon's discarded wife, the woman everyone thought was just a pretty ornament.
Now, every powerful man wants the queen Leon threw away a renowned scientist seeking partnership, a financial titan proposing an empire, and an actor offering devotion. Each sees the brilliance Leon ignored.
Then Leon discovers the truth: Aria's sacrifices, her secret double life, and the daughter she's been raising without him. For the first time, the man who once took her for granted must fight for her love. But can he compete with men who valued her from the beginning?
A story of love, betrayal, and power where the king must kneel before the queen who never needed saving.
Let Them Kneel

Let Them Kneel

244.2k Views · Ongoing · My Fantasy Stories
Kaelani spent her life believing she was wolfless.
Cast out by her pack. Forgotten by the Lycans.
She lived among humans—quiet, invisible, tucked away in a town no one looked at twice.

But when her first heat comes without warning, everything changes.

Her body ignites. Her instincts scream. And something primal stirs beneath her skin—
summoning a big, bad Alpha who knows exactly how to quench her fire.

When he claims her, it’s ecstasy and ruin.

For the first time, she believes she’s been accepted.
Seen.
Chosen.

Until he leaves her the next morning—
like a secret never to be spoken.

But Kaelani is not what they thought.
Not wolfless. Not weak.
There is something ancient inside her. Something powerful. And it’s waking.

And when it does—
they’ll all remember the girl they tried to erase.

Especially him.

She’ll be the dream he keeps chasing… the one thing that ever made him feel alive.

Because secrets never stay buried.
And neither do dreams.
Luna Rising

Luna Rising

209.8k Views · Ongoing · khholderwrites
They thought she was a broken omega.
They were wrong.
Seren was stolen as a newborn and raised in a pack that treated her as disposable. Beaten and imprisoned, she survives by hiding her strength—until a mating ball brings fate crashing into her life.
With enemies willing to sell lives and a past tied to the throne, Seren must rise…or die.
A dark werewolf romance of power, fate, and vengeance.
The MC President’s Runaway

The MC President’s Runaway

176.5k Views · Completed · Allison Slaughter
Rina Blakely was raised to believe money could solve anything. Born into an upper-middle-class family, she had every opportunity life could offer—until the night her parents died and the man she was engaged to showed his true colors.
Controlling. Violent. Obsessed.
The night he tried to kill her, Rina disappeared.
With nothing but the clothes on her back and a fake name, she flees halfway across the country, landing in the unforgiving deserts of New Mexico. Broke and desperate, she takes a job dancing at the Devil’s Den, a notorious strip club where cash is king and questions aren’t asked.
She swears she’ll leave the moment she saves enough money.
Then Max Torres walks through the door.
As the ruthless president of the Sons of Doom Motorcycle Club, Max has spent years building a brotherhood feared across the Southwest. He doesn’t mix business with women, and he definitely doesn’t get involved with strippers.
Until Rina.
The beautiful dancer with haunted eyes is hiding something, and every instinct tells Max she’s in danger. When the man hunting her finally tracks her down, he’ll discover one brutal truth.
Rina Blakely may have run from one monster…
But now she’s under the protection of an even more dangerous one.