My Boyfriend and Brothers Chose My Best Friend
1.1k Views · Ongoing · Hachimitsu
The five of us had an unwritten rule: we never discussed plans. We guessed.
What to eat, where to go, who was paying—everything was a guessing game.
They called it the kind of connection you developed after ten years together.
Somehow, I was always the only one who got it wrong.
Two weeks before our fall vacation, I asked the group chat, “Where are we going?”
All four of them gave the same answer: “Guess.”
I asked my boyfriend privately. Without giving it much thought, he said, “I hear Lake Tahoe's beautiful in October.”
That night, I booked a flight to Reno.
The next day, my best friend, Olivia Bennett, posted a picture of palm trees in our chat.
“Can't wait for that ocean breeze!”
I canceled Reno and booked Key West.
A day later, my oldest brother shared a post about hiking in Death Valley.
“Every guy should see the desert at least once.”
I canceled again and booked Las Vegas so I could go to Death Valley.
In seven days, I changed my reservation eight times. I thought I'd finally figured it out.
Then, the night before we left, I saw a group chat on my boyfriend's phone. A chat without me.
Olivia: “I've decided. San Diego.”
My oldest brother answered immediately. “Sounds good. I'll buy the tickets now.”
My other brother: “Oh, and somebody remember to give Chris a hint about the right place.”
My boyfriend sent an OK emoji.
Only then did I understand. There hadn't been a destination to guess. They'd been waiting for Olivia to choose while I kept guessing alone.
This time, I didn't want to change my ticket.
What to eat, where to go, who was paying—everything was a guessing game.
They called it the kind of connection you developed after ten years together.
Somehow, I was always the only one who got it wrong.
Two weeks before our fall vacation, I asked the group chat, “Where are we going?”
All four of them gave the same answer: “Guess.”
I asked my boyfriend privately. Without giving it much thought, he said, “I hear Lake Tahoe's beautiful in October.”
That night, I booked a flight to Reno.
The next day, my best friend, Olivia Bennett, posted a picture of palm trees in our chat.
“Can't wait for that ocean breeze!”
I canceled Reno and booked Key West.
A day later, my oldest brother shared a post about hiking in Death Valley.
“Every guy should see the desert at least once.”
I canceled again and booked Las Vegas so I could go to Death Valley.
In seven days, I changed my reservation eight times. I thought I'd finally figured it out.
Then, the night before we left, I saw a group chat on my boyfriend's phone. A chat without me.
Olivia: “I've decided. San Diego.”
My oldest brother answered immediately. “Sounds good. I'll buy the tickets now.”
My other brother: “Oh, and somebody remember to give Chris a hint about the right place.”
My boyfriend sent an OK emoji.
Only then did I understand. There hadn't been a destination to guess. They'd been waiting for Olivia to choose while I kept guessing alone.
This time, I didn't want to change my ticket.


















































